Lundorff Marie, Bonanno George A, Johannsen Maja, O'Connor Maja
Unit for Bereavement Research, Department of Psychology and Behavioural Sciences, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark; Unit for Psycho-Oncology and Health Psychology, Department of Oncology, Aarhus University Hospital and Department of Psychology and Behavioural Sciences, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark.
Department of Clinical Psychology, Columbia University, Teachers College, New York, USA.
J Psychiatr Res. 2020 Oct;129:168-175. doi: 10.1016/j.jpsychires.2020.06.030. Epub 2020 Jul 24.
Research suggests variation in how grief develops across time, and gender may account for some of this variation. However, gender differences in growth patterns of the newly codified ICD-11 prolonged grief disorder (PGD) are unknown. This study examined gender-specific variances in grief trajectories in a registry-sampled cohort of 857 spousal bereaved individuals (69.8% female). Participants completed self-report questionnaires of PGD symptoms at 2, 6, and 11 months post-loss. Using Growth Mixture Modeling, four PGD trajectories emerged: resilient characterized by low symptoms (64.4%), moderate-stable characterized by moderate symptoms (20.4%), recovery characterized by elevated symptoms showing a decrease over time (8.4%), and prolonged grief characterized by continuous elevated symptoms (6.8%). Similar proportions of men and women comprised the four trajectories. Gender influenced the parameter estimates of the prolonged grief trajectory as men evidenced more baseline symptoms (higher intercept) than women did and a decreasing symptom-level (negative slope), while women showed symptom-increase over time (positive slope). The prolonged grief trajectory captured the largest proportion of probable PGD cases in both genders. Low optimism and low mental health predicted membership in this class. Altogether, the absolute majority of both men and women followed a low-symptom resilient trajectory. While a comparable minority followed a high-symptom prolonged grief trajectory, men and women within this trajectory expressed varying symptom development. Men expressed prolonged grief as an acute, decreasing reaction, whereas women showed an adjourned, mounting grief reaction. This study suggests that gender may influence symptom development in highly distressed individuals across early bereavement.
研究表明,悲伤情绪随时间发展存在差异,而性别可能是造成这种差异的部分原因。然而,新编纂的国际疾病分类第11版(ICD - 11)中持续性悲伤障碍(PGD)的发展模式在性别上的差异尚不清楚。本研究在一个登记抽样队列中,对857名丧偶者(69.8%为女性)的悲伤轨迹中的性别特异性差异进行了研究。参与者在丧偶后的2个月、6个月和11个月完成了PGD症状的自我报告问卷。使用生长混合模型,出现了四种PGD轨迹:以低症状为特征的恢复型(64.4%)、以中度症状为特征的中度稳定型(20.4%)、以症状随时间下降为特征的恢复型(8.4%)以及以症状持续升高为特征的持续性悲伤型(6.8%)。男性和女性在这四种轨迹中的比例相似。性别影响了持续性悲伤轨迹的参数估计,因为男性比女性表现出更多的基线症状(更高的截距)和症状水平下降(负斜率),而女性则表现出症状随时间增加(正斜率)。持续性悲伤轨迹在两性中捕获了最大比例的可能PGD病例。低乐观度和低心理健康状况预示着属于这一类别。总体而言,绝大多数男性和女性都遵循低症状的恢复型轨迹。虽然相当少数人遵循高症状的持续性悲伤轨迹,但该轨迹中的男性和女性表现出不同的症状发展。男性将持续性悲伤表现为一种急性的、逐渐减少的反应,而女性则表现出延迟的、逐渐增加的悲伤反应。这项研究表明,性别可能会影响丧亲早期高度痛苦个体的症状发展。