Menon Sudha, O Sandesh, Anand Debish, Menon Girish
Department of Ophthalmology, Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.
Department of Neurosurgery, Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.
J Neurosci Rural Pract. 2020 Jul;11(3):385-394. doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1709270. Epub 2020 May 11.
Spheno-orbital meningiomas (SOMs) constitute a rare cause for orbital proptosis and visual impairment. This study aims to share our outcome experience with regard to vision and exophthalmos following the surgical management of 17 patients with SOM. Retrospective analysis of the case records of all surgically treated SOMs in the last 10 years. Exophthalmos index (EI) was calculated based on preoperative magnetic resonance imaging/computed tomography imaging. Vision was assessed using the Snellen's chart and Goldman's perimeter. Orbital volume was calculated using three-dimensional volume rendering assisted region-of-interest computation. Preoperative duration of symptoms and extent of surgery were the other predictors analyzed. Patients' age ranged from 17 to 72 years (mean, 50.57 y; median, 50.0 years). Women represented 13 (76.4%) of the entire study group. Proptosis (14/17; 82.4%) and visual impairment (14/17; 82.3%) were the two most common presenting complaints followed by headache (12/17; 70.1%). Gross total resection (GTR) was achieved in only 2 of the 17 patients (11.8%). Majority of the tumors were benign World Health Organization Grade I meningiomas (14/17; 84%). Mean follow-up time for the entire cohort was 56 months. Postoperatively, proptosis improved in nine (64.3%) and remained static in the rest five (35.7%) of patients. Four patients (28.6%) improved in vision following surgery. Vision remained static in eight patients (57.1%). Vision deteriorated in two (14.3%) patients who had severe preoperative visual deficits. New onset oculomotor palsy, trigeminal dysfunction, and mechanical ocular motility restriction were noticed in three (17.6%), two (11.2%), and six (35.3%) patients, respectively. The mean preoperative orbital volume was 21.68 ± 3.2 cm and the mean postoperative orbital volume was 23.72 ± 3.4 cm . Orbital volume was inversely related to EI. Optic canal (OC) deroofing and extensive orbital wall decompression facilitated visual improvement and proptosis reduction. None of the variables including orbital volume proved to be statistically significant in predicting outcome. SOMs constitute a rare subgroup of skull base meningiomas that pose considerable surgical challenges. A surgical strategy aimed at safe maximal resection rather than aggressive GTR provides favorable outcome with less morbidity. Adequate bony decompression of the orbital walls and OC provides satisfactory improvements in proptosis and vision. Residual disease is common, but the risk of symptomatic recurrence is low especially when combined with adjuvant radiotherapy. Visual outcome is likely to be poor in patients presenting with severely compromised vision.
蝶骨 - 眶脑膜瘤(SOMs)是眼眶突出和视力损害的罕见原因。本研究旨在分享我们对17例SOM患者手术治疗后视力和眼球突出情况的治疗结果经验。
对过去10年中所有接受手术治疗的SOM患者的病例记录进行回顾性分析。根据术前磁共振成像/计算机断层扫描成像计算眼球突出指数(EI)。使用斯内伦视力表和戈德曼视野计评估视力。使用三维容积渲染辅助感兴趣区域计算来计算眼眶容积。分析的其他预测因素包括术前症状持续时间和手术范围。
患者年龄范围为17至72岁(平均50.57岁;中位数50.0岁)。女性占整个研究组的13例(76.4%)。眼球突出(14/17;82.4%)和视力损害(14/17;82.3%)是最常见的两个主诉,其次是头痛(12/17;70.1%)。17例患者中仅有2例(11.8%)实现了全切除(GTR)。大多数肿瘤为世界卫生组织I级良性脑膜瘤(14/17;84%)。整个队列的平均随访时间为56个月。术后,9例(64.3%)患者的眼球突出有所改善,其余5例(35.7%)保持稳定。4例(28.6%)患者术后视力有所改善。8例(57.1%)患者视力保持稳定。2例(14.3%)术前视力严重受损的患者视力恶化。分别有3例(17.6%)、2例(11.2%)和6例(35.3%)患者出现新发动眼神经麻痹、三叉神经功能障碍和机械性眼球运动受限。术前平均眼眶容积为21.68±3.2 cm³,术后平均眼眶容积为23.72±3.4 cm³。眼眶容积与EI呈负相关。视神经管(OC)去顶术和广泛的眶壁减压有助于视力改善和眼球突出减轻。包括眼眶容积在内的所有变量在预测结果方面均无统计学意义。
SOMs是颅底脑膜瘤的一个罕见亚组,带来了相当大的手术挑战。旨在安全最大限度切除而非激进全切除的手术策略能带来较好的治疗结果且并发症较少。对眶壁和OC进行充分的骨性减压可使眼球突出和视力得到满意改善。残留疾病很常见,但症状性复发的风险较低,尤其是联合辅助放疗时。视力严重受损的患者视力预后可能较差。