Tahko Tuomas E
Br J Philos Sci. 2020 Sep;71(3):799-825. doi: 10.1093/bjps/axy044. Epub 2019 Aug 2.
Biochemical kinds such as proteins pose interesting problems for philosophers of science, as they can be studied from the points of view of both biology and chemistry. The relationship between the biological functions of biochemical kinds and the microstructures that they are related to is the key question. This leads us to a more general discussion about ontological reductionism, microstructuralism, and multiple realization at the biology-chemistry interface. On the face of it, biochemical kinds seem to pose a challenge for ontological reductionism and hence motivate a dual theory of chemical and biological kinds, a type of pluralism about natural kinds. But it will be argued that the challenge, which is based on multiple realization, can be addressed. The upshot is that there are reasonable prospects for ontological reductionism about biochemical kinds, which corroborates natural kind monism. 1Introduction2Functions: Aetiological or Goal-Directed?3Moonlighting and Multiple Determinations4The Powers-Based Subset Strategy5The Case of Haemoglobin6Haemoglobin and the Problem of Lower-Level Vengeance7Multiple Realization and (Higher-Order) Interest Relativeness8The Prospects for Ontological Reductionism.
诸如蛋白质这样的生物化学种类给科学哲学家们提出了有趣的问题,因为它们可以从生物学和化学两个角度进行研究。生物化学种类的生物学功能与其相关的微观结构之间的关系是关键问题。这引导我们对本体论还原论、微观结构主义以及生物学 - 化学界面的多重实现进行更广泛的讨论。乍一看,生物化学种类似乎对本体论还原论构成了挑战,从而促使人们提出一种关于化学和生物种类的二元论,即一种关于自然种类的多元论。但本文将论证,基于多重实现的这一挑战是可以应对的。结果是,对于生物化学种类的本体论还原论存在合理的前景,这证实了自然种类一元论。1引言2功能:病因学的还是目标导向的?3兼职与多重决定4基于能力的子集策略5血红蛋白的例子6血红蛋白与低级报复问题7多重实现与(高阶)利益相关性8本体论还原论的前景