Department of Pediatrics, Advanced Pediatrics Centre, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER), Chandigarh, India.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2020 Aug 17;20(1):761. doi: 10.1186/s12913-020-05649-w.
Provision of timely care to critically ill children is essential for good outcome. Referral from smaller peripheral hospitals to higher centers for intensive care is common. However, lack of an organized referral and feedback system compromises optimal care. We studied the quality of referral letters coming to our Emergency Department (ED) with respect to their demography, association with severity of illness and mortality before and after referral education.
Our study was completed in three phases in the Pediatric ED; Pre-intervention, Intervention and Post intervention phases. Quality of referral letter was matched with a quality checklist proforma and graded as 'good', 'fair' and 'poor' if it scored > 7, 5-7 and < 5 points respectively. A peer reviewed referral education module was prepared using case studies, expert opinions, and lacunae observed in the first phase and administered to health care providers (HCP's) of referring hospitals. Quality of referral letter was compared between pre and post intervention phases.
Most referrals belonged to the neighboring states of Punjab (48.2%) and Haryana (22.4%). Major referring hospitals were from public sector (80.9%), of which the teaching hospitals topped the list (53.6%). Government run ambulance services (85.5%) was commonest mode of transport used and need for a PICU bed and/or mechanical ventilation (50.4%) was the commonest reason for referral. The post intervention phase saw a significant decline in the proportion of poor (93.2 vs.78.2%; p = 0.001) and a significant increase in the proportion of fair (6.1 vs 18%; p = 0.001) and good referral letters (0.7 vs 18%; p = 0.001). The proportion of children with physiological decompensation at triage had reduced significantly in the post intervention phase [513 out of 1403 (36.5%) vs. 310 out of 957 (32.3%); p = 0.001].
Referral education had significantly improved the quality of referral letters. Proportion of children with physiological decompensation at triage had decreased significantly after referral module. This change suggests sensitization of the peripheral hospitals towards a better referral process. Continued multifaceted approach will be required for sustained and increased benefits.
及时为危重症儿童提供治疗对于获得良好的预后至关重要。将患儿从较小的周边医院转诊至更高水平的重症监护中心的情况较为常见。然而,缺乏组织化的转诊和反馈系统会影响到最佳治疗效果。我们研究了我院急诊部(ED)收到的转诊信的质量,这些转诊信涉及转诊前和转诊后的患者人口统计学特征、与疾病严重程度和死亡率的相关性,以及在转诊教育前后的情况。
我们的研究在儿科 ED 进行了三个阶段:干预前、干预中和干预后。使用质量检查表对转诊信质量进行评分,如果得分>7、5-7 和 <5 分,则分别评为“好”、“中”和“差”。使用病例研究、专家意见和第一阶段观察到的空白内容,为转诊医院的医疗保健提供者(HCP)制定了同行评审的转诊教育模块,并对其进行了管理。比较了干预前和干预后的转诊信质量。
大多数转诊来自旁遮普邦(48.2%)和哈里亚纳邦(22.4%)。主要转诊医院来自公共部门(80.9%),其中教学医院最多(53.6%)。使用最普遍的转运方式是政府运行的救护车服务(85.5%),转诊的最常见原因是需要 PICU 病床和/或机械通气(50.4%)。干预后阶段,差的转诊信比例显著下降(93.2%比 78.2%;p=0.001),而中、好的转诊信比例显著增加(6.1%比 18%;p=0.001;0.7%比 18%;p=0.001)。干预后阶段,分诊时出现生理失代偿的患儿比例显著下降[1403 例中有 513 例(36.5%)比 957 例中有 310 例(32.3%);p=0.001]。
转诊教育显著提高了转诊信的质量。分诊时出现生理失代偿的患儿比例在实施转诊模块后显著下降。这一变化表明,周边医院对转诊过程的敏感性有所提高。需要采取多方面的持续措施,以实现持续和更大的收益。