From the IMPAQ International, LLC, Oakland, California.
J Patient Saf. 2020 Sep;16(3S Suppl 1):S12-S15. doi: 10.1097/PTS.0000000000000749.
The aim of this systematic review was to examine the most effective and feasible methods for environmental cleaning and decontamination to prevent Clostridioides difficile infection (CDI) in health care settings.
A systematic search of the databases CINAHL and MEDLINE was conducted from 2008 to 2018 for English language articles with search terms including "Clostridium difficile," and related medical subject headings, in combination with terms like "disinfection," "decontamination," and "no-touch decontamination."
Twelve studies and 2 systematic reviews were selected for inclusion in this review. The studies were primarily in hospitals (10/12) and used a before-after approach. The studied interventions included cleaning and decontamination with a chlorine-based agent (i.e., bleach; 2 studies), standard cleaning plus the use of hydrogen peroxide decontamination (3 studies), and standard bleach cleaning plus the use of ultraviolet light decontamination (6 studies), and there was 1 study about launderable bed covers. The interventions ranged in frequency, duration, and the area selected for cleaning and decontamination (e.g., all patient rooms versus only CDI patients' rooms). Studies showed significant reductions in CDI associated with use of bleach (versus quaternary ammonium compound) and hydrogen peroxide decontamination after standard bleach cleaning (versus bleach cleaning alone). Four of 6 studies found significant reductions in CDI after the implementation of ultraviolet light decontamination after standard bleach cleaning.
The studied practices for environmental cleaning and decontamination were associated with significant decreases in facility-level CDI rates in most of the reviewed studies; however, study quality was low. Implementation challenges are worthy of further examination.
本系统评价旨在研究预防医疗机构中艰难梭菌感染(CDI)最有效的可行环境清洁和消毒方法。
从 2008 年至 2018 年,使用 CINAHL 和 MEDLINE 数据库,对包括“艰难梭菌”和相关医学主题词在内的英文文献进行系统检索,并结合“消毒”、“去污”和“无接触去污”等术语进行检索。
共选择了 12 项研究和 2 项系统评价纳入本综述。这些研究主要在医院进行(10/12),并采用了前后对照的方法。研究中的干预措施包括使用含氯制剂(如漂白剂)进行清洁和消毒(2 项研究)、标准清洁加过氧化氢消毒(3 项研究)、标准漂白剂清洁加紫外线消毒(6 项研究),以及 1 项关于可洗床罩的研究。干预措施的频率、持续时间和选择的清洁消毒区域(例如,所有病房与仅 CDI 患者的病房)各不相同。研究表明,使用漂白剂(与季铵化合物相比)和标准漂白剂清洁后使用过氧化氢消毒(与单独使用漂白剂清洁相比)与 CDI 相关的减少显著。在标准漂白剂清洁后实施紫外线消毒的 6 项研究中有 4 项发现 CDI 显著减少。
在大多数回顾性研究中,所研究的环境清洁和消毒方法与设施层面 CDI 发生率的显著降低相关;然而,研究质量较低。实施挑战值得进一步研究。