Department of Dentomaxillofacial Radiology, School of Dentistry, Istanbul Medipol University, Istanbul, Turkey.
Department of Endodontics, School of Dentistry, Turgut Özal Bulvarı, Avalon yerleşkesi, Beykent University, Büyükçekmece, Istanbul, Turkey.
J Dent Educ. 2020 Oct;84(10):1166-1172. doi: 10.1002/jdd.12362. Epub 2020 Aug 19.
This study was designed to investigate Artificial Intelligence in Dental Radiology (AIDR) videos on YouTube in terms of popularity, content, reliability, and educational quality.
Two researchers systematically searched about AIDR on YouTube on January 27, 2020, by using the terms "artificial intelligence in dental radiology," "machine learning in dental radiology," and "deep learning in dental radiology." The search was performed in English, and 60 videos for each keyword were assessed. Video source, content type, time since upload, duration, and number of views, likes, and dislikes were recorded. Video popularity was reported using Video Power Index (VPI). The accuracy and reliability of the source of information were measured using the adapted DISCERN score. The quality of the videos was measured using JAMAS and modified Global Quality Score (mGQS) and content via Total Concent Evaluation (TCE).
There was high interobserver agreement for DISCERN (intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC]: 0.975; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.957-0.985; P: 0.000; P < 0.05) and mGQS (ICC: 0.904; 95% CI: 0.841-0.943; P: 0.000; P < 0.05). Academic source videos had higher DISCERN, GQS, and TCE, revealing both reliability and quality. Also, positive relationship of VPI with mGQS (30.1%) (P: 0.035) and DISCERN (38.1%) (P: 0.007) is detected. The scores revealed 51.9% relationship between mGQS and DISCERN (P: 0.001); and educational quality predictor scores revealed 62.5% relationship between TCE and GQS (P: 0.000).
Despite the limited number of relevant videos, YouTube involves reliable and quality videos that can be used by dentists about learning AIDR.
本研究旨在调查 YouTube 上的牙科放射人工智能 (AIDR) 视频的受欢迎程度、内容、可靠性和教育质量。
两名研究人员于 2020 年 1 月 27 日在 YouTube 上使用“牙科放射人工智能”、“牙科放射机器学习”和“牙科放射深度学习”等术语对 AIDR 进行了系统搜索。搜索以英文进行,每个关键词评估 60 个视频。记录视频来源、内容类型、上传时间、时长和观看次数、点赞数和差评数。使用视频影响力指数 (VPI) 报告视频的受欢迎程度。使用改编后的 DISCERN 评分测量信息来源的准确性和可靠性。使用 JAMAS 和改良全球质量评分 (mGQS) 以及总集中评估 (TCE) 测量视频质量。
DISCERN(组内相关系数 [ICC]:0.975;95%置信区间 [CI]:0.957-0.985;P:0.000;P<0.05)和 mGQS(ICC:0.904;95%CI:0.841-0.943;P:0.000;P<0.05)的观察者间一致性很高。学术来源视频的 DISCERN、GQS 和 TCE 较高,显示出可靠性和质量。此外,还检测到 VPI 与 mGQS(30.1%)(P:0.035)和 DISCERN(38.1%)(P:0.007)之间的正相关关系。评分显示 mGQS 和 DISCERN 之间存在 51.9%的关系(P:0.001);教育质量预测评分显示 TCE 和 GQS 之间存在 62.5%的关系(P:0.000)。
尽管相关视频数量有限,但 YouTube 上仍包含可靠且高质量的视频,牙医可以通过这些视频了解 AIDR 知识。