Department of Health Policy and Management, Yale School of Public Health, New Haven, CT, USA.
Addiction. 2021 Mar;116(3):651-657. doi: 10.1111/add.15235. Epub 2020 Sep 28.
Responses to the 2019 US outbreak of 'e-cigarette or vaping product use-associated lung injury' (EVALI) ranged from temporary restrictions on nicotine e-cigarette sales to critiques of state cannabis policies. However, if either mass-marketed nicotine e-cigarettes or cannabis use per se drove this outbreak, as opposed to an additive in regionally available black-market e-liquids, states' rates of vaping and/or cannabis use should predict their EVALI prevalence. This study tests that relationship.
Observational study of EVALI data from US states' health departments SETTING: United States.
All US states (n = 50).
The outcome of interest was each state's total EVALI cases per 12-64-year-old resident-an age group covering most EVALI patients-as reported in the second week of January 2020. Predictors are 2017-18 rates of adult e-cigarette use and past-month cannabis use by state.
The average state EVALI prevalence was 1.4 cases per 100 000 12-64-year-olds. Maps suggest a high-prevalence cluster comprising seven contiguous states in the northern Midwest. EVALI cases per capita were negatively associated with rates of vaping and past-month cannabis use, with the preferred specification's coefficients at -0.239 [95% confidence interval (CI) = -0.441, -0.037; P = 0.02] and -0.086 (95% CI = -0.141, -0.031; P = 0.003), respectively. Robustness checks supported this finding.
In the United States, states with higher rates of e-cigarette and cannabis use prior to the 2019 'e-cigarette or vaping product use-associated lung injury' (EVALI) outbreak had lower EVALI prevalence. These results suggest that EVALI cases did not arise from e-cigarette or cannabis use per se, but rather from locally distributed e-liquids or additives most prevalent in the affected areas.
针对 2019 年美国“电子烟或蒸气产品使用相关肺损伤”(EVALI)爆发,各国的应对措施从暂时限制尼古丁电子烟销售到对州内大麻政策的批评不一。然而,如果导致此次疫情爆发的是大众市场上的尼古丁电子烟或大麻的使用,而不是地区性黑市电子烟液中的添加剂,那么各州的电子烟或大麻使用率应该可以预测其 EVALI 流行率。本研究检验了这种关系。
美国各州卫生部门 EVALI 数据的观察性研究
美国
全美所有 50 个州
本研究的兴趣结果是每个州在 2020 年 1 月第二周报告的每 12-64 岁居民(涵盖大多数 EVALI 患者的年龄组)的 EVALI 总病例数。预测因子是 2017-18 年成人电子烟使用率和各州过去一个月大麻使用率。
各州 EVALI 平均流行率为每 100000 名 12-64 岁居民 1.4 例。地图显示,在北部中西部的七个相邻州中存在一个高流行率集群。人均 EVALI 病例数与电子烟使用和过去一个月大麻使用呈负相关,首选规格的系数为-0.239(95%置信区间[CI]:-0.441,-0.037;P=0.02)和-0.086(95%CI:-0.141,-0.031;P=0.003)。稳健性检查支持这一发现。
在美国,2019 年“电子烟或蒸气产品使用相关肺损伤”(EVALI)爆发前电子烟和大麻使用率较高的州 EVALI 流行率较低。这些结果表明,EVALI 病例并非源于电子烟或大麻的使用本身,而是源于在受影响地区最为普遍的当地分布的电子烟液或添加剂。