Modak Maitreyi B, Gray Amy Z
Department of General Medicine, Royal Children's Hospital, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Department of Paediatrics, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
J Paediatr Child Health. 2021 Jan;57(1):96-102. doi: 10.1111/jpc.15135. Epub 2020 Aug 26.
The literature suggests that feedback is wanted and needed in clinical medicine and specifically on ward rounds, yet it is often lacking. This study aimed to examine junior doctor perceptions of education and feedback on ward rounds in one clinical department at a tertiary paediatric hospital and the key influences on these perceptions.
Six semi-structured focus groups were conducted over a period of 9 months comprising of 20 participants (post-graduate year 1-5) in a general medical department of a tertiary paediatric hospital. Qualitative analysis was performed on focus group transcripts using an inductive approach and codes and themes were generated in an iterative fashion with checking of themes between two researchers.
Feedback experiences were largely positive compared to previous rotations. Three overarching themes were identified which influenced trainee perceptions of education and feedback on ward rounds. These were: consultant influences (e.g. educational engagement), trainee influences (e.g. active seeking of feedback), and structural factors (e.g. organisational constraints).
Despite positive feedback experiences, the need to improve feedback for our junior doctors is clear, but how to do this remains challenging when navigating work-learning tensions. The notion of the educational alliance between the consultant and trainee is a potential useful solution, but it requires deliberate effort and dedicated time to establish given our increasingly complex and busy clinical environments.
文献表明,临床医学中需要反馈,尤其是在查房时,但反馈往往缺失。本研究旨在调查一家三级儿科医院一个临床科室的初级医生对查房教育及反馈的看法,以及对这些看法的关键影响因素。
在9个月的时间里开展了6次半结构化焦点小组讨论,参与者为一家三级儿科医院普通内科的20名医生(研究生1至5年级)。采用归纳法对焦点小组讨论记录进行定性分析,两名研究人员以迭代方式生成代码和主题,并对主题进行核对。
与之前的轮岗相比,反馈体验总体上是积极的。确定了三个总体主题,这些主题影响了实习生对查房教育及反馈的看法。它们分别是:带教顾问的影响(如教育参与度)、实习生的影响(如积极寻求反馈)和结构因素(如组织限制)。
尽管反馈体验是积极的,但改善对初级医生的反馈的必要性显而易见,然而在应对工作与学习的紧张关系时,如何做到这一点仍然具有挑战性。带教顾问与实习生之间教育联盟的理念是一个潜在的有用解决方案,但鉴于我们的临床环境日益复杂和繁忙,需要刻意努力并投入专门时间来建立这种联盟。