Mc Laughlin Leah, Spence Susan, Noyes Jane
School of Health Sciences, Bangor University, Bangor, UK.
The Welsh Health Specialised Services Committee, Welsh Renal Clinical Network, Caerphilly, UK.
BMJ Open. 2020 Sep 1;10(9):e036872. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-036872.
To identify the shared research priorities of patients, caregivers and multidisciplinary renal health and social care professionals across Wales for integrated renal health and social care in Wales.
Research priority setting exercise adapted from the James Lind Alliance national priority setting partnership framework in UK healthcare.
Two workshops: one in North Wales with patients, caregivers and multidisciplinary renal health and social care professionals and one in South Wales with the Welsh Renal Clinical Network (commissioners of renal services in Wales). Additional input provided from stakeholders via email correspondence and face to face communications.
Academics n=14, patients n=16, family/carers n=6, multidisciplinary renal healthcare professionals n=40, local authority councils n=3, renal charities n=6 wider third sector organisations n=8, renal industries n=4, Welsh government social care n=3, renal service commissioners n=8.
38 research priority questions grouped into 10 themes were agreed. The themes included: (1) integrating health and social care, (2) education, (3) acute kidney injury, (4) chronic kidney disease and cardiovascular disease, (5) transplantation, (6) dialysis, (7) personalised medicines, (8) cross-cutting priorities, (9) specific social contexts and (10) transitional services and children. Research questions were broad and covered a range of health and social care topics. Patient and professional perspectives broadly overlapped. Research priority setting activities revealed gaps in knowledge in overall service provision and potential areas for service improvement.
Mapping priorities in health services and social care highlighted the research needed to support renal health services delivery and commissioning in Wales.
确定威尔士患者、护理人员以及多学科肾脏健康与社会护理专业人员对于威尔士肾脏健康与社会护理整合的共同研究重点。
借鉴英国医疗保健领域詹姆斯·林德联盟国家优先事项设定伙伴关系框架进行的研究重点设定活动。
举办了两场研讨会:一场在北威尔士,参会人员有患者、护理人员以及多学科肾脏健康与社会护理专业人员;另一场在南威尔士,参会人员有威尔士肾脏临床网络(威尔士肾脏服务的委托方)。利益相关者还通过电子邮件通信和面对面交流提供了额外意见。
学者14名、患者16名、家庭/护理人员6名、多学科肾脏医疗专业人员40名、地方当局委员会3个、肾脏慈善机构6个、其他第三部门组织8个、肾脏行业4个、威尔士政府社会护理部门3名、肾脏服务委托方8名。
商定了38个研究重点问题,分为10个主题。这些主题包括:(1)健康与社会护理整合;(2)教育;(3)急性肾损伤;(4)慢性肾病与心血管疾病;(5)移植;(6)透析;(7)个性化药物;(8)跨领域重点;(9)特定社会背景;(10)过渡服务与儿童。研究问题范围广泛,涵盖了一系列健康与社会护理主题。患者和专业人员的观点大致重叠。研究重点设定活动揭示了整体服务提供方面的知识差距以及服务改进的潜在领域。
梳理健康服务和社会护理的重点突出了威尔士支持肾脏健康服务提供和委托所需的研究。