Fernández-Carballido Cristina, Tornero Carolina, Castro-Villegas M Carmen, Galindez Eva, García-Llorente José Francisco, García-Vivar María Luz, Joven-Ibáñez Beatriz, Juanola Xavier, Urrego-Laurín Claudia, López-Medina Clementina, Almodovar Raquel, Martínez-Alberola Nieves, Ruiz-Jimeno Teresa, de Miguel Eugenio
Rheumatology Department, Hospital Universitario San Juan de Alicante, Alicante, Spain
Rheumatology Department, Hospital Universitario La Paz, Madrid, Spain.
RMD Open. 2020 Sep;6(2). doi: 10.1136/rmdopen-2020-001345.
To estimate the 6-year radiographic progression of sacroiliitis in patients with early spondyloarthritis (SpA).
Sacroiliac joint (SIJ) radiographs (baseline and 6 years) of 94 patients with recent-onset SpA from the Esperanza cohort were scored, blindly and in a random order, by nine readers. The modified New York criteria were used to define the presence of sacroiliitis. As the gold standard for radiographic (r) sacroiliitis, the categorical opinion of at least five readers was used. Progression was defined as the shift from non-radiographic (nr) to r-sacroiliitis.
In the 94 SIJ radiographs (baseline and 6 years), 78/94 (83%) pairs of radiographs had not changed from baseline to 6 years. Sacroiliitis was present in 20 patients at baseline (21.3%) and in 18 (19.2%) patients at 6 years; 11 patients had sacroiliitis at both the baseline and final visits; 9 patients changed from baseline r-sacroiliitis to nr-sacroiliitis at 6 years, and 7 changed from baseline nr-sacroiliitis to r-sacroiliitis at 6 years. The mean continuous change score (range: -8 to +8) was 2.80 at baseline and 2.55 at 6 years (mean net progression of -0.25). The reliability of the readers was fair (mean inter-reader kappa of 0.375 (0.146-0.652) and mean agreement of 73.7% (58.7-90%)).
In the early SpA Esperanza cohort, progression from nr-axSpA to r-axSpA over 6 years was not observed, although the SIJ radiographs scoring has limitations to detect low levels of radiographic progression.
评估早期脊柱关节炎(SpA)患者骶髂关节炎6年的影像学进展情况。
来自埃斯佩兰萨队列的94例近期发病的SpA患者的骶髂关节(SIJ)X线片(基线和6年时)由9名阅片者进行盲法随机评分。采用改良纽约标准来定义骶髂关节炎的存在。作为影像学(r)骶髂关节炎的金标准,采用至少5名阅片者的分类意见。进展定义为从非影像学(nr)骶髂关节炎转变为r骶髂关节炎。
在94例SIJ X线片(基线和6年时)中,78/94(83%)对X线片从基线到6年未发生变化。20例患者在基线时存在骶髂关节炎(21.3%),18例(19.2%)患者在6年时存在骶髂关节炎;11例患者在基线和末次随访时均有骶髂关节炎;9例患者在6年时从基线r骶髂关节炎转变为nr骶髂关节炎,7例患者在6年时从基线nr骶髂关节炎转变为r骶髂关节炎。连续变化评分的平均值(范围:-8至+8)在基线时为2.80,6年时为2.55(平均净进展为-0.25)。阅片者的可靠性一般(阅片者间平均kappa值为0.375(0.146 - 0.652),平均一致性为73.7%(58.7 - 90%))。
在早期SpA埃斯佩兰萨队列中,尽管SIJ X线片评分在检测低水平影像学进展方面存在局限性,但未观察到6年内从nr轴向SpA进展为r轴向SpA的情况。