Knights Jonathan, Heidary Zahra, Cochran Jeffrey M
Otsuka Pharmaceutical Development & Commercialization, Princeton, NJ, United States.
JMIR Ment Health. 2020 Sep 10;7(9):e21378. doi: 10.2196/21378.
Adherence to medication is often represented in the form of a success percentage over a period of time. Although noticeable changes to aggregate adherence levels may be indicative of unstable medication behavior, a lack of noticeable changes in aggregate levels over time does not necessarily indicate stability. The ability to detect developing changes in medication-taking behavior under such conditions in real time would allow patients and care teams to make more timely and informed decisions.
This study aims to develop a method capable of identifying shifts in behavioral (medication) patterns at the individual level and subsequently assess the presence of such shifts in retrospective clinical trial data from patients with serious mental illness.
We defined the term adherence volatility as "the degree to which medication ingestion behavior fits expected behavior based on historically observed data" and defined a contextual anomaly system around this concept, leveraging the empirical entropy rate of a stochastic process as the basis for formulating anomaly detection. For the presented methodology, each patient's evolving behavior is used to dynamically construct the expectation bounds for each future interval, eliminating the need to rely on model training or a static reference sequence.
Simulations demonstrated that the presented methodology identifies anomalous behavior patterns even when aggregate adherence levels remain constant and highlight the temporal dependence inherent in these anomalies. Although a given sequence of events may present as anomalous during one period, that sequence should subsequently contribute to future expectations and may not be considered anomalous at a later period-this feature was demonstrated in retrospective clinical trial data. In the same clinical trial data, anomalous behavioral shifts were identified at both high- and low-adherence levels and were spread across the whole treatment regimen, with 77.1% (81/105) of the population demonstrating at least one behavioral anomaly at some point in their treatment.
Digital medicine systems offer new opportunities to inform treatment decisions and provide complementary information about medication adherence. This paper introduces the concept of adherence volatility and develops a new type of contextual anomaly detection, which does not require an a priori definition of normal and allows expectations to evolve with shifting behavior, removing the need to rely on training data or static reference sequences. Retrospective analysis from clinical trial data highlights that such an approach could provide new opportunities to meaningfully engage patients about potential shifts in their ingestion behavior; however, this framework is not intended to replace clinical judgment, rather to highlight elements of data that warrant attention. The evidence provided here identifies new areas for research and seems to justify additional explorations in this area.
药物依从性通常以一段时间内的成功百分比形式呈现。虽然总体依从水平的显著变化可能表明用药行为不稳定,但随着时间推移总体水平缺乏显著变化并不一定意味着稳定。在这种情况下实时检测用药行为中正在发生的变化的能力,将使患者和护理团队能够做出更及时、明智的决策。
本研究旨在开发一种能够在个体层面识别行为(用药)模式变化的方法,并随后在患有严重精神疾病患者的回顾性临床试验数据中评估此类变化的存在情况。
我们将依从性波动性定义为“药物摄入行为符合基于历史观察数据的预期行为的程度”,并围绕这一概念定义了一个上下文异常系统,利用随机过程的经验熵率作为制定异常检测的基础。对于所提出的方法,每个患者不断变化的行为被用于动态构建每个未来时间段的预期界限,无需依赖模型训练或静态参考序列。
模拟表明,所提出的方法即使在总体依从水平保持不变时也能识别异常行为模式,并突出了这些异常中固有的时间依赖性。虽然给定的一系列事件在某一时期可能表现为异常,但该序列随后应有助于形成未来的预期,并且在后期可能不被视为异常——这一特征在回顾性临床试验数据中得到了证明。在同一临床试验数据中,在高依从水平和低依从水平上都识别出了异常行为变化,并且这些变化分布在整个治疗方案中,77.1%(81/105)的患者在治疗的某个阶段表现出至少一种行为异常。
数字医学系统为指导治疗决策和提供有关药物依从性的补充信息提供了新机会。本文介绍了依从性波动性的概念,并开发了一种新型的上下文异常检测方法,该方法不需要对正常情况进行先验定义,并且允许预期随着行为的变化而演变,无需依赖训练数据或静态参考序列。来自临床试验数据的回顾性分析表明,这种方法可以为有意义地让患者了解其摄入行为的潜在变化提供新机会;然而,这个框架并非旨在取代临床判断,而是为了突出值得关注的数据元素。此处提供的证据确定了新的研究领域,似乎也证明了在该领域进行更多探索的合理性。