Wolpaw Jed T, Uhlig Elizabeth, Isaac Gillian R, Dwivedi Priyanka, Lekowski Robert W, Toy Serkan
J Educ Perioper Med. 2020 Apr 1;22(2):E643. doi: 10.46374/volxxii-issue2-wolpaw. eCollection 2020 Apr-Jun.
In our current digital age, textbooks have been supplemented or supplanted by multiple online modalities for knowledge acquisition. Trainees, often from a younger generation than their program directors (PDs), prefer options such as podcasts, videos, and question banks. We sought to identify whether an exists between PDs and trainees regarding what is assigned and what is used.
A national cross-sectional survey was conducted in the United States in 2018-2019 to characterize anesthesiology resident and PD perceptions of academic knowledge acquisition.
Of the 149 PDs, 85 completed the survey (57%). Of the 85 PDs, 36 forwarded the survey to residents. Of the 1414 residents who received the survey, 503 residents responded to the survey (36%). The PDs thought residents used didactics, assigned reading, and scheduled simulations more than residents reported ( < .001). Residents reported using self-directed learning more ( = .004). Most residents (74.1%) reported using textbooks or online reading materials. Those residents reporting >70th percentile on the In-Training Exam used textbooks or online materials more than those who reported low scores (<30th percentile; = .001).
There is a discrepancy between PD and resident views on where and how knowledge acquisition occurs. Asynchronous forms of education (especially podcasts) are popular, but they are rarely assigned by programs. Although residents have a wide variety of learning preferences, textbook and online reading may be associated with higher In-Training Exam scores (a common way that knowledge acquisition is measured). The PDs should consider providing multiple options for optimizing knowledge acquisition, including textbook reading, to meet resident preferences and maximize testing success.
在当今的数字时代,教科书已被多种在线学习方式所补充或取代,用于知识获取。实习生通常比他们的项目主任(PD)年轻一代,他们更喜欢播客、视频和题库等学习方式。我们试图确定在分配的学习内容和实际使用的内容方面,PD和实习生之间是否存在差异。
2018 - 2019年在美国进行了一项全国性横断面调查,以了解麻醉科住院医师和PD对学术知识获取的看法。
149名PD中,85名完成了调查(57%)。在这85名PD中,36名将调查转发给了住院医师。在收到调查的1414名住院医师中,503名住院医师回复了调查(36%)。PD认为住院医师使用教学法、指定阅读材料和安排的模拟练习比住院医师报告的更多(P <.001)。住院医师报告更多地使用自主学习(P =.004)。大多数住院医师(74.1%)报告使用教科书或在线阅读材料。在培训考试中成绩处于第70百分位数以上的住院医师比成绩低(<第30百分位数)的住院医师更多地使用教科书或在线材料(P =.001)。
在知识获取的地点和方式上,PD和住院医师的观点存在差异。异步教育形式(尤其是播客)很受欢迎,但项目很少指定。尽管住院医师有各种各样的学习偏好,但教科书和在线阅读可能与更高的培训考试成绩相关(这是衡量知识获取的一种常见方式)。PD应考虑提供多种优化知识获取的选项,包括教科书阅读,以满足住院医师的偏好并最大限度地提高考试成功率。