University of Milano-Bicocca, Milan, Italy.
Sociol Health Illn. 2020 Nov;42(8):1902-1917. doi: 10.1111/1467-9566.13176. Epub 2020 Sep 17.
There has been a growing interest in the study of masculinity and its intersection with health. However, and despite epidemiological data showing men's general disadvantage in health, there are only a few empirical studies that explore men's experiences of chronic illness. Drawing on empirical data collected in qualitative research on masculinity and autoimmune diabetes, this article investigates the multiple ways in which gender may intersect with health, in an attempt to go beyond the widespread thesis that 'masculinity is bad for men's health'. In line with more recent critical perspectives on the study of men's health that have challenged this oversimplistic assumption, this work further problematises masculinity in relation to health and illness. In-depth interviews have been conducted with 40 young/adult diabetic men from working/middle-class backgrounds. The findings show that gender might intersect health in complex ways and diabetic men can embody and re-signify health practices in order to fulfil or redefine dominant ideals of masculinity. From the analysis, three different 'diabetic masculinities' have been identified and will be discussed: the Diabetic Quantified Self, the Athlete and the Free Spirit.
人们对男性气质及其与健康的交叉点越来越感兴趣。然而,尽管流行病学数据显示男性在健康方面普遍处于不利地位,但只有少数实证研究探讨了男性患慢性病的经历。本文借鉴了关于男性气质和自身免疫性糖尿病的定性研究中收集的实证数据,探讨了性别可能与健康交叉的多种方式,试图超越“男性气质对男性健康有害”这一普遍观点。与最近对男性健康研究的更具批判性的观点一致,这些观点对将男性气质与健康和疾病联系起来的这种过于简单化的假设提出了质疑,本研究进一步使男性气质与健康和疾病的关系复杂化。我们对来自工人/中产阶级背景的 40 名年轻/成年糖尿病男性进行了深入访谈。研究结果表明,性别可能以复杂的方式与健康相互作用,糖尿病男性可以体现和重新定义健康行为,以实现或重新定义主导的男性气质理想。通过分析,确定了三种不同的“糖尿病男性气质”,并将进行讨论:量化自我的糖尿病患者、运动员和自由精神者。