Department of Diagnostic Radiology, Oulu University Hospital, Oulu, Finland.
Research Unit of Medical Imaging, Physics and Technology, University of Oulu, Oulu, Finland.
J Appl Clin Med Phys. 2020 Oct;21(10):210-217. doi: 10.1002/acm2.13021. Epub 2020 Sep 21.
To investigate the replacement of conventional grid by air gap in axiolateral hip radiographs. The optimal air gap distance was studied with respect to radiation dose and image quality using phantom images, as well as 26 patient axiolateral hip radiographs.
The CDRAD phantom, along with polymethylmethacrylate slabs with thicknesses of 10.0, 14.6, and 20.0 cm was employed. The inverse image quality index and dose area product (DAP), as well as their combination, so called figure-of-merit (FOM) parameter, were evaluated for these images, with air gaps from 20 to 50 cm in increments of 10 cm. Images were compared to those acquired using a conventional grid utilized in hip radiography. Radiation dose was measured and kept constant at the surface of the detector by using a reference dosimeter. Verbal consent was asked from 26 patients to participate to the study. Air gap distances from 20 to 50 cm and tube current-time products from 8 to 50 mAs were employed. Exposure index, DAP, as well as patient height and weight were recorded. Two radiologists evaluated the image quality of 26 hip axiolateral projection images on a 3-point nondiagnostic - good/sufficiently good - too good scale. Source-to-image distance of 200 cm and peak tube voltage of 90 kVp were used in both studies.
Based on the phantom study, it is possible to reduce radiation dose by replacing conventional grid with air gap without compromising image quality. The optimal air gap distance appears to be 30 cm, based on the FOM analysis. Patient study corroborates this observation, as sufficiently good image quality was found in 24 of 26 patient radiographs, with 7 of 26 images obtained with 30 cm air gap. Thus, air gap method, with an air gap distance of 30 cm, is recommended in axiolateral hip radiography.
研究在髋关节正位侧位片中外展侧用空气间隙取代传统栅格的效果。使用体模图像以及 26 例患者髋关节正位侧位片研究了在辐射剂量和图像质量方面的最佳空气间隙距离。
使用 CDRAD 体模和 10.0、14.6 和 20.0cm 厚的聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯板。对这些图像进行反向质量指数和剂量面积乘积(DAP)评估,以及它们的组合,即优值(FOM)参数评估,空气间隙距离为 20-50cm,间隔为 10cm。将这些图像与髋关节摄影中使用的传统栅格获得的图像进行比较。使用参考剂量计在探测器表面测量并保持恒定的辐射剂量。要求 26 名患者自愿参与该研究。使用 20-50cm 的空气间隙距离和 8-50mAs 的管电流时间乘积。记录曝光指数、DAP 以及患者的身高和体重。两位放射科医生使用 3 分制(无诊断-良好/足够好-非常好)对 26 例髋关节侧位投影图像的图像质量进行评估。在这两项研究中均使用源像距 200cm 和峰值管电压 90kVp。
基于体模研究,如果不影响图像质量,可以用空气间隙代替传统栅格来降低辐射剂量。基于 FOM 分析,最佳空气间隙距离似乎为 30cm。患者研究证实了这一观察结果,因为在 26 例患者的放射片中,有 24 例获得了足够好的图像质量,其中 7 例使用 30cm 空气间隙获得。因此,推荐在髋关节正位侧位片中使用空气间隙方法,空气间隙距离为 30cm。