Department of Economics and Finance, University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Department of Economics and Management, Free University of Bozen-Bolzano, Bozen-Bolzano, Italy.
Health Econ. 2020 Dec;29(12):1705-1720. doi: 10.1002/hec.4162. Epub 2020 Sep 22.
We examine the impact of a major earthquake that unexpectedly affected the Canterbury region of New Zealand on a wide-range of birth outcomes, including birth weight, gestational age, and an indicator of general newborn health. We control for observed and unobserved differences between pregnant women in the area affected by the earthquake and other pregnant women by including mother fixed effects in all of our regression models. We extend the previous literature by comparing the impact of the initial unexpected earthquake to the impacts of thousands of aftershocks that occurred in the same region over the 18 months following the initial earthquake. We find that exposure to these earthquakes reduced gestational age, increased the likelihood of having a late birth, and negatively affected newborn health-with the largest effects for earthquakes that occurred in the first and third trimesters of pregnancy. Our estimates are similar when we focus on just the impact of the initial earthquake or, in contrast, on all earthquakes controlling for endogenous location decisions using an instrumental variables approach. This suggests that the previous estimates in the literature that use this approach are likely unbiased and that treatment effects are homogenous in the population. We present supporting evidence that the likely channel for these adverse effects is maternal stress.
我们考察了一场突如其来的大地震对新西兰坎特伯雷地区广泛的生育结果(包括出生体重、胎龄和新生儿整体健康指标)的影响。我们通过在所有回归模型中纳入母亲固定效应,控制了受灾地区和其他地区孕妇之间可观察到和不可观察到的差异。我们通过将最初意外地震的影响与随后 18 个月内同一地区发生的数千次余震的影响进行比较,扩展了先前的文献。我们发现,暴露于这些地震会降低胎龄,增加晚产的可能性,并对新生儿健康产生负面影响,其中对怀孕第一和第三 trimester 发生的地震影响最大。当我们仅关注初始地震的影响,或者相反,使用工具变量方法控制内生位置决策来关注所有地震时,我们的估计值是相似的。这表明,文献中使用这种方法的先前估计值可能是无偏的,并且人群中的治疗效果是同质的。我们提供了支持性证据,表明这些不利影响的可能途径是母体应激。