Department of Surgery, Michigan Medicine, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
School of Nursing, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
Med Educ. 2021 Mar;55(3):336-343. doi: 10.1111/medu.14380. Epub 2020 Oct 12.
Qualitative research approaches are increasingly integrated into medical education research to answer relevant questions that quantitative methodologies cannot accommodate. However, researchers have found that traditional qualitative methodological approaches reflect the foundations and objectives of disciplines whose aims are recognizably different from the medical education domain of inquiry (Thorne, 2016, Interpretive description. New York, NY: Routledge). Interpretive description (ID), a widely used qualitative research method within nursing, offers an accessible and theoretically flexible approach to analysing qualitative data within medical education research. ID is an appropriate methodological alternative for medical education research, as it can address complex experiential questions while producing practical outcomes. It allows for the advancement of knowledge surrounding educational experience without sacrificing methodological integrity that long-established qualitative approaches provide.
In this paper, we present interpretive description as a useful research methodology for qualitative approaches within medical education. We then provide a toolkit for medical education researchers interested in incorporating interpretive description into their study design. We propose a coherent set of strategies for identifying analytical frameworks, sampling, data collection, analysis, rigour and the limitations of ID for medical education research. We conclude by advocating for the interpretive description approach as a viable and flexible methodology for medical education research.
定性研究方法越来越多地被纳入医学教育研究,以回答定量方法无法解决的相关问题。然而,研究人员发现,传统的定性方法反映了基础学科和目标学科的基础和目标,这些学科的目标与医学教育研究领域明显不同(Thorne,2016,解释性描述。纽约,NY:Routledge)。解释性描述(ID)是护理中广泛使用的一种定性研究方法,为医学教育研究中分析定性数据提供了一种易于使用且理论上灵活的方法。ID 是医学教育研究的一种合适的方法选择,因为它可以解决复杂的经验问题,同时产生实际的结果。它允许在不牺牲长期确立的定性方法提供的方法完整性的情况下,围绕教育经验推进知识。
在本文中,我们将解释性描述作为医学教育中定性方法的有用研究方法进行介绍。然后,我们为有兴趣将解释性描述纳入其研究设计的医学教育研究人员提供了一个工具包。我们提出了一套连贯的策略,用于确定分析框架、抽样、数据收集、分析、严谨性以及 ID 对医学教育研究的局限性。最后,我们主张解释性描述方法是医学教育研究的一种可行且灵活的方法。