Lorber M I, Flechner S M, Van Buren C T, Sorensen K, Kerman R H, Kahan B D
Am J Kidney Dis. 1987 Jun;9(6):476-84. doi: 10.1016/s0272-6386(87)80074-4.
Forty-nine patients among 360 who received renal transplants under cyclosporine (CsA)/prednisone (Pred) immunosuppression required alteration of the immunosuppressive regimen because of intractable nephrotoxicity. Twenty-five patients, converted totally to azathioprine (Aza)/Pred, suffered intractable nephrotoxicity with no associated evidence suggesting ongoing rejection. The results with Aza/Pred conversion were disappointing because of an unacceptably high incidence of rejection and allograft loss. Twenty-four patients with intractable CsA nephrotoxicity were, therefore, treated using an alternative approach combining Aza with aggressive CsA dose reduction, and continued Pred therapy. All patients tolerated initiation of Aza without complication; allograft rejection was not common. Renal function improved for 23 of the 24 (96%) CsA/Aza/Pred patients with mean serum creatinine levels falling from 3.5 +/- 0.5 mg/dL to 2.2 +/- 0.4 mg/dL after a mean follow-up of 14 months (P less than .001). Among 18 patients observed at least 12 months, seven (39%) enjoyed serum creatinine values less than or equal to 2 mg/dL. Nine CsA/Aza/Pred-treated patients (37.5%) required hospitalization because of infectious complications, all of which resolved with temporary reduction of immunosuppression and specific antimicrobial therapy when indicated. One patient sustained acute allograft rejection as a result of patient noncompliance, and one patient on a seemingly appropriate CsA/Aza/Pred dose responded initially to steroid pulse antirejection therapy; however, renal function again worsened. Two patients developed progressive renal dysfunction due to chronic rejection, and returned to dialysis 13 and 17 months, respectively, following initiation of CsA/Aza/Pred. Overall, the actuarial graft survival for CsA/Aza/Pred-treated patients was 100% at 1 year, and 84% at 2 years.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
在360例接受环孢素(CsA)/泼尼松(Pred)免疫抑制治疗的肾移植患者中,49例因难以控制的肾毒性而需要改变免疫抑制方案。25例完全转换为硫唑嘌呤(Aza)/Pred的患者出现难以控制的肾毒性,且无相关证据表明存在持续性排斥反应。由于排斥反应和移植肾丢失的发生率高得令人无法接受,Aza/Pred转换的结果令人失望。因此,24例患有难以控制的CsA肾毒性的患者采用了一种替代方法,即联合使用Aza并积极降低CsA剂量,同时继续进行Pred治疗。所有患者在开始使用Aza时均未出现并发症;移植肾排斥反应并不常见。24例CsA/Aza/Pred患者中有23例(96%)肾功能得到改善,平均血清肌酐水平在平均随访14个月后从3.5±0.5mg/dL降至2.2±0.4mg/dL(P<0.001)。在18例观察至少12个月的患者中,7例(39%)的血清肌酐值小于或等于2mg/dL。9例接受CsA/Aza/Pred治疗的患者(37.5%)因感染并发症而需要住院治疗,所有这些并发症在暂时降低免疫抑制并在必要时进行特异性抗菌治疗后均得到解决。1例患者因患者不依从导致急性移植肾排斥反应,1例接受看似合适的CsA/Aza/Pred剂量的患者最初对类固醇冲击抗排斥治疗有反应;然而,肾功能再次恶化。2例患者因慢性排斥反应出现进行性肾功能不全,分别在开始CsA/Aza/Pred治疗13个月和17个月后重新开始透析。总体而言,接受CsA/Aza/Pred治疗的患者1年时的移植肾实际生存率为100%,2年时为84%。(摘要截短至250字)