Comparison of four serotests for the detection of Dirofilaria immitis infection in dogs.

Three hundred two dogs were tested with 4 serotests for heartworm antigen (AG) or antibody (AB) and with the Knott test. The 4 serotests evaluated were an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for adult heartworm-specific AB (AB-ELISA), a quantitative, indirect immunofluorescent assay (IFA) for adult heartworm-specific AB (AB-IFA), an IFA test for microfilaria (MF)-specific AB (MF-IFA), and an ELISA for adult heartworm AG (AG-ELISA). The presence of heartworms was ascertained in all dogs by necropsy examination. Of 302 dogs, 20 (6.6%) had heartworms in the heart at necropsy. Of infected dogs, 9 (45%) had occult infections. Test sensitivities were 75%, 95%, 70%, and 75% for the AB-ELISA, AB-IFA, MF-IFA, and AG-ELISA, respectively. Test specificities were 85% (AB-ELISA), 77% (AB-IFA), 87% (MF-IFA), and 99% (AG-ELISA). The best agreement between serotest results and necropsy findings was obtained with the AG-ELISA (97%). The 4 serotests detected 86% (AB-ELISA), 100% (AB-IFA), 67% (MF-IFA), and 78% (AG-ELISA) of the dogs with occult heartworm infection. A significant (P less than 0.05) association between intestinal parasitism and positive heartworm test results was found with only AB-IFA. Seemingly, the Knott test, or some other concentration method for detecting circulating MF should be the first heartworm test performed. If the examination for MF is negative, the dog has clinical signs, and radiographic findings are suggestive of occult heartworm infection, then a serotest for adult heartworm AG is recommended.