Madjar Nir, Bachner Yaacov G, Kushnir Talma
School of Education, Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan 5290002, Israel.
Department of Public Health, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Beersheba, Israel.
Natl Med J India. 2019 Sep-Oct;32(5):298-302. doi: 10.4103/0970-258X.296240.
Previous research on medical students' motivation mostly overlooked an important concept, namely, mastery-avoidance goals. The mastery-avoidance goal is defined as engaging in a task to avoid losing knowledge or skills that have already been acquired. We aimed to explore the role of mastery-avoidance goals in changes occurring in low frustration tolerance (LFT) levels over a span of one academic year. This approach enables us to understand which type of motivational orientation is expected to explain most adaptive educational outcomes.
First year medical students (n = 241) participating in a physician-patient communication course completed the surveys of motivational orientations and LFT at the beginning and at the end of the academic year. A confirmatory factor analysis supported the construct validity of the motivational orientations structure.
Cross-lagged analysis using structural equation modelling revealed that the mastery-approach goal was negatively related to the progression of LFT while mastery-avoidance goal was positively related.
The findings suggest that what matters is not merely the level of motivation, but rather the type of motivational orientations that students pursue. Encouraging students to improve their current skills, while discouraging competitiveness and reducing fear of losing competence, may enhance the effectiveness of medical training programmes.
以往对医学生动机的研究大多忽略了一个重要概念,即掌握-回避目标。掌握-回避目标被定义为参与一项任务以避免失去已获得的知识或技能。我们旨在探讨掌握-回避目标在一学年内低挫折承受力(LFT)水平变化中所起的作用。这种方法使我们能够了解哪种动机取向有望解释最具适应性的教育成果。
参加医患沟通课程的一年级医学生(n = 241)在学年开始和结束时完成了动机取向和LFT的调查。验证性因素分析支持了动机取向结构的建构效度。
使用结构方程模型的交叉滞后分析表明,掌握-趋近目标与LFT的进展呈负相关,而掌握-回避目标与LFT的进展呈正相关。
研究结果表明,重要的不仅仅是动机水平,而是学生追求的动机取向类型。鼓励学生提高当前技能,同时抑制竞争并减少对失去能力的恐惧,可能会提高医学培训项目的有效性。