Tomaník Lukáš, Muchová Eva, Slavíček Petr
Department of Physical Chemistry, University of Chemistry and TechnologyTechnická 5, 16628 Prague 6, Czech Republic.
Phys Chem Chem Phys. 2020 Oct 15;22(39):22357-22368. doi: 10.1039/d0cp02768e.
Solvation free energies can be advantageously estimated by cluster-continuum approaches. They proved useful especially for systems with high charge density. However, the clusters are assumed to be single minimum rigid species. It is an invalid condition for larger clusters and it complicates the assessment of convergence with the system size. We present a new variant of the cluster-continuum approach, "Ensemble Cluster-Continuum" scheme, where the single minima problem is circumvented by a thermodynamic cycle based on vertical quantities (ionization energies, electron affinities). Solvation free energies are calculated for a charged-neutralized system and solvation correction for the vertical quantities is estimated for an ensemble of structures from molecular dynamics simulation. We test the scheme on a set of various types of anions and cations, we study the convergence of the cluster-continuum model and assess various types of errors. The quantitative data depend on the applied continuum solvation model yet the convergence is analogous. We argue that the assessment of convergence provides a measure of the reliability of the calculated solvation energies.
溶剂化自由能可以通过团簇-连续介质方法进行有利的估算。它们已证明特别适用于具有高电荷密度的系统。然而,团簇被假定为单一极小值的刚性物种。对于较大的团簇来说,这是一个无效的条件,并且它使与系统大小相关的收敛性评估变得复杂。我们提出了一种团簇-连续介质方法的新变体,即“系综团簇-连续介质”方案,其中通过基于垂直量(电离能、电子亲和能)的热力学循环规避了单一极小值问题。对一个带电中和的系统计算溶剂化自由能,并对分子动力学模拟得到的一组结构的垂直量估算溶剂化校正。我们在一组各种类型的阴离子和阳离子上测试该方案,研究团簇-连续介质模型的收敛性并评估各种类型的误差。定量数据取决于所应用的连续介质溶剂化模型,但收敛情况是类似的。我们认为收敛性评估提供了一种衡量所计算的溶剂化能可靠性的方法。