Khanna Richa, Singh Rajeev Kumar, Singhal Rameshwari
Department of Paediatric and Preventive Dentistry, King George's Medical University, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India.
Department of Periodontology, King George's Medical University, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India.
J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent. 2020 Jul-Sep;38(3):293-303. doi: 10.4103/JISPPD.JISPPD_33_20.
Basic behavioral guidance (BBG) skills help in delivery of quality health care in pediatric dentistry. The complex nature of these skills, warrants analyzing actions performed. An appropriate scientific way to do this is by "reflection." Hence, the present study was designed to introduce "reflection of action" as means for learning BBG skills by undergraduates in pediatric dentistry.
Participants (dental undergraduate) performed oral prophylaxis (two visits) in pediatric patients (age 3-7 years) with application of BBG skills, under video recording. They were instructed regarding "reflection on action." The learners then reviewed own videos and wrote reflections. Reflections were assessed on Boud's 4R framework and feedback was given by the faculty. Reflective writing was repeated for a second visit. Knowledge of the learners in using reflections for learning was assessed by retrospective pretest posttest questionnaire. Video recordings were scored for BBG skills. Acceptability of the intervention was addressed by satisfaction questionnaire.
There was a significant improvement in the knowledge of participants in using reflections for learning these skills. All participants were able to "revisit" (R1 level under Boud's 4R framework) patient encounter in their written reflections. Sixteen participants exhibited shift toward higher levels in the next visit. Video scores of learners also improved significantly over both visits. Students were satisfied with the content, delivery, and relevance of the new educational intervention.
The strong need of improving BBG skills in pediatric dentistry was met by "reflection on action." There was improvement in the knowledge of students in using reflections for learning and application of behavior guidance skills and was well accepted.
基本行为指导(BBG)技能有助于在儿童牙科领域提供高质量的医疗服务。这些技能的复杂性使得有必要对所采取的行动进行分析。一种合适的科学方法是通过“反思”。因此,本研究旨在引入“行动反思”,作为牙科本科学生学习儿童牙科BBG技能的一种手段。
参与者(牙科本科生)在3至7岁的儿科患者身上进行口腔预防治疗(两次就诊),同时应用BBG技能,并进行录像。他们接受了关于“行动反思”的指导。学习者随后观看自己的视频并撰写反思。根据博德的4R框架对反思进行评估,并由教师给予反馈。第二次就诊时重复进行反思性写作。通过回顾性前测后测问卷评估学习者在利用反思进行学习方面的知识。对录像中的BBG技能进行评分。通过满意度问卷来评估干预措施的可接受性。
参与者在利用反思学习这些技能方面的知识有显著提高。所有参与者在书面反思中都能够“回顾”(博德4R框架下的R1水平)与患者的接触情况。16名参与者在下一次就诊时表现出向更高水平的转变。学习者的录像评分在两次就诊中也有显著提高。学生们对新的教育干预措施的内容、实施方式和相关性感到满意。
“行动反思”满足了儿童牙科领域提高BBG技能的迫切需求。学生在利用反思学习和应用行为指导技能方面的知识有所提高,并且该方法得到了很好的接受。