Glasgow Dental Hospital and School; Glasgow, UK; Honorary Clinical Teacher in Paediatric Dentistry, Academic Unit of Oral Health, Dentistry and Society, School of Clinical Dentistry, University of Sheffield, UK.
School of Dental Sciences, Newcastle University, UK.
Br Dent J. 2022 May;232(10):729-734. doi: 10.1038/s41415-022-3993-4. Epub 2022 May 27.
Reflection is an essential component of the learning process that helps to elicit deeper learning. In healthcare, this uses experiential activities to produce knowledge that compels the clinician to change their practice. Deep reflection allows one to explore emotions associated with challenging learning experiences, empowering reinterpretation of these experiences and removing barriers to further learning. Reflection is a key requirement of dental education at all stages. This paper aims to explore the existing literature on reflective practice in dentistry and identify areas for further research to improve reflective practice within dentistry.Traditional methods of reflecting through written means are not facilitating the deep reflection which is desired. A systematic overhaul of reflective practice is suggested, involving a shift away from structured written reflections. There is little evidence to inform the most appropriate format for reflective practice in dental education. There is a need for further research to determine the effectiveness of reflective practice in dental education, particularly as a move away from structured written reflection to more creative reflective opportunities are encouraged. Greater exploration of barriers to reflection in dentistry is indicated, with consideration to how these may be overcome and a need to engage regulatory bodies in system-wide changes.
反思是学习过程中的一个重要组成部分,有助于引出更深入的学习。在医疗保健领域,这利用体验式活动来产生知识,促使临床医生改变他们的实践。深度反思可以让人们探索与具有挑战性的学习体验相关的情绪,从而重新解释这些体验,并消除进一步学习的障碍。反思是牙科教育各个阶段的关键要求。本文旨在探讨牙科领域中关于反思实践的现有文献,并确定进一步研究的领域,以改善牙科领域的反思实践。传统的书面反思方式并不能促进深度反思。建议对反思实践进行系统的彻底改革,从有结构的书面反思转变。几乎没有证据可以说明在牙科教育中最适合的反思实践形式。需要进一步研究来确定反思实践在牙科教育中的有效性,特别是当鼓励从有结构的书面反思转变为更具创造性的反思机会时。需要更深入地探讨牙科反思的障碍,并考虑如何克服这些障碍,以及需要让监管机构参与系统范围的变革。