Mayweg-Paus Elisabeth, Zimmermann Maria, Le Nguyen-Thinh, Pinkwart Niels
Einstein Center Digital Future | Department of Education Studies | Digital Knowledge Management in Higher Education, Humboldt University of Berlin, Unter den Linden 6, 10099 Berlin, Germany.
Department of Computer Science | Research Group Computer Science Education | Computer Science and Society, Humboldt University of Berlin, Unter den Linden 6, 10099 Berlin, Germany.
Educ Inf Technol (Dordr). 2021;26(2):2053-2089. doi: 10.1007/s10639-020-10345-7. Epub 2020 Sep 30.
In everyday life, people seek, evaluate, and use online sources to underpin opinions and make decisions. While education must promote the skills people need to critically question the sourcing of online information, it is important, more generally, to understand how to successfully promote the acquisition of any skills related to seeking online information. This review outlines technologies that aim to support users when they collaboratively seek online information. Upon integrating psychological-pedagogical approaches on trust in and the sourcing of online information, argumentation, and computer-supported collaborative learning, we reviewed the literature ( = 95 journal articles) on technologies for collaborative online information seeking. The technologies we identified either addressed collaborative online information seeking as an exclusive process for searching for online information or, alternatively, addressed online information seeking within the context of a more complex learning process. Our review was driven by three main research questions: We aimed to understand whether and how the studies considered 1) the role of trust and critical questioning in the sourcing of online information, 2) the learning processes at play when information seekers engage in collaborative argumentation, and 3) what affordances are offered by technologies that support users' collaborative seeking of online information. The reviewed articles that focused exclusively on technologies for seeking online information primarily addressed aspects of cooperation (e.g., task management), whereas articles that focused on technologies for integrating the processes of information seeking into the entire learning processes instead highlighted aspects of collaborative argumentation (e.g., exchange of multiple perspectives and critical questioning in argumentation). Seven of the articles referred to trust as an aspect of seekers' sourcing strategies. We emphasize how researchers', users', and technology developers' consideration of collaborative argumentation could expand the benefits of technological support for seeking online information.
在日常生活中,人们寻找、评估并利用网络资源来支撑观点和做出决策。虽然教育必须提升人们批判性质疑网络信息来源所需的技能,但更普遍而言,理解如何成功促进与网络信息搜索相关的任何技能的习得也很重要。本综述概述了旨在在用户协作搜索网络信息时提供支持的技术。在整合关于网络信息的信任与来源、论证以及计算机支持的协作学习的心理教育学方法后,我们查阅了关于协作式网络信息搜索技术的文献(95篇期刊文章)。我们确定的技术要么将协作式网络信息搜索作为搜索网络信息的专属过程来处理,要么在更复杂的学习过程背景下处理网络信息搜索。我们的综述由三个主要研究问题驱动:我们旨在了解这些研究是否以及如何考虑1)信任和批判性质疑在网络信息来源中的作用,2)信息搜索者进行协作论证时所涉及的学习过程,以及3)支持用户协作搜索网络信息的技术提供了哪些功能。专门关注网络信息搜索技术的综述文章主要探讨了合作方面(如任务管理),而关注将信息搜索过程整合到整个学习过程中的技术的文章则更强调协作论证方面(如论证中多种观点的交流和批判性质疑)。其中七篇文章将信任视为搜索者来源策略的一个方面。我们强调研究人员、用户和技术开发者对协作论证地考虑如何能够扩大技术支持对网络信息搜索的益处。