Department of Public Health, Montclair State University, Montclair, New Jersey, USA
Division of Epidemiology, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Long Island City, New York, USA.
J Epidemiol Community Health. 2021 Mar;75(3):258-263. doi: 10.1136/jech-2020-214089. Epub 2020 Oct 7.
Law enforcement-related deaths of unarmed black Americans may lead black communities to distrust public institutions. Our study quantifies the impact of law enforcement-related deaths of black New York residents on the use of hospital emergency departments (ED) during 2013-2016.
We used regression discontinuity models stratified by race and time period (2013-2015 and 2015-2016) to estimate the impact of law enforcement-related deaths on ED rates. Dates of deaths and media reports were from the Mapping Police Violence database. We calculated the daily overall and condition-specific ED visit rates from the New York's Statewide Planning and Research Cooperative System.
There were 14 law enforcement-related deaths of unarmed black New York residents from 2013 to 2016. In 2013-2014, the ED rate among black New Yorkers decreased by 7.7 visits per 100 000 black New Yorkers (5% less than the average ED rate) using the date of media report as the cut-off with a 2-week exposure window. No changes in ED rates were noted for black New Yorkers in 2015-2016 or for white New Yorkers in either time period. Models using the date of death followed a similar pattern.
The decrease in ED rates among black New Yorkers immediately following media reports of law enforcement-related deaths involving unarmed black New Yorkers during 2013-2014 may represent potentially harmful delays in healthcare. Reforms implemented during 2015-2016 might have modified the impact of these deaths. Further investigation into the population health impacts of law enforcement-related deaths is needed.
执法部门导致的非武装黑人美国人死亡事件可能导致黑人社区对公共机构失去信任。本研究量化了 2013-2016 年期间执法部门导致的纽约黑人居民死亡事件对医院急诊部门(ED)使用情况的影响。
我们使用按种族和时间段分层的回归不连续性模型(2013-2015 年和 2015-2016 年)来估计执法部门相关死亡事件对 ED 率的影响。死亡日期和媒体报道来自 Mapping Police Violence 数据库。我们从纽约州全州规划和研究合作系统中计算了每日整体和特定条件的 ED 就诊率。
2013 年至 2016 年期间,有 14 名非武装的纽约黑人居民死于执法部门相关事件。在 2013-2014 年,使用媒体报道日期作为截止日期并采用两周的暴露窗口,每 100000 名纽约黑人中 ED 就诊率下降了 7.7 次就诊(比平均 ED 就诊率低 5%)。在 2015-2016 年期间,没有观察到黑人纽约居民的 ED 就诊率发生变化,也没有观察到白人纽约居民在两个时间段的 ED 就诊率发生变化。使用死亡日期的模型呈现出类似的模式。
2013-2014 年期间,在涉及非武装的纽约黑人的执法部门相关死亡事件的媒体报道后,黑人纽约居民的 ED 就诊率下降,这可能代表潜在的有害的医疗保健延误。2015-2016 年期间实施的改革可能改变了这些死亡事件的影响。需要进一步调查执法部门相关死亡事件对人群健康的影响。