Kimball Kelly A, Roecker Christopher B, Hoyt Katie
J Chiropr Educ. 2021 Oct 1;35(2):209-214. doi: 10.7899/JCE-19-10.
Impostor phenomenon is expressed by feelings of self-doubt and the belief that one is unintelligent. The purpose of this research was to describe the prevalence of impostor phenomenon among students enrolled in a doctor of chiropractic program and to evaluate for any differences in the rates of impostor phenomenon between males and females.
We performed an anonymous cross-sectional, online survey of all students enrolled in the doctor of chiropractic program at 2 campuses of 1 chiropractic college. We reported the point prevalence of impostor phenomenon and used χ2 to evaluate the differences in impostor phenomenon among males and females. We also evaluated for between-group differences for 4 other demographic factors believed to influence impostor phenomenon.
We received 406 survey responses (34% response rate). Impostor phenomenon was reported in 39% of students responding to our survey. Approximately 46% of all females and 32% of all males met the criteria for impostor phenomenon, and females had significantly higher rates of impostor phenomenon (p = .005). The following variables were not associated with impostor phenomenon: year in which students were enrolled; marital status; whether chiropractic was their first career; and type of clinical experience the student encountered.
Our findings demonstrate that over a third of students enrolled in a doctor of chiropractic program met the criteria for impostor phenomenon, and females were significantly more likely to experience impostor phenomenon. The results from this survey are similar to those reported in other healthcare educational settings.
冒名顶替现象表现为自我怀疑的感觉以及认为自己不聪明的信念。本研究的目的是描述整脊疗法博士项目学生中冒名顶替现象的发生率,并评估男性和女性在冒名顶替现象发生率上的差异。
我们对一所整脊疗法学院两个校区所有注册整脊疗法博士项目的学生进行了一项匿名横断面在线调查。我们报告了冒名顶替现象的时点患病率,并使用卡方检验评估男性和女性在冒名顶替现象上的差异。我们还评估了其他4个人口统计学因素在组间的差异,这些因素被认为会影响冒名顶替现象。
我们收到了406份调查问卷回复(回复率为34%)。在回复我们调查的学生中,39%的学生报告有冒名顶替现象。所有女性中约46%以及所有男性中约32%符合冒名顶替现象的标准,女性的冒名顶替现象发生率显著更高(p = 0.005)。以下变量与冒名顶替现象无关:学生入学年份;婚姻状况;整脊疗法是否是他们的第一职业;以及学生所经历的临床经验类型。
我们的研究结果表明,超过三分之一注册整脊疗法博士项目的学生符合冒名顶替现象的标准,并且女性更有可能经历冒名顶替现象。本次调查结果与其他医疗保健教育环境中报告的结果相似。