Department of Microbiology, State TB Training and Demonstration Centre, Government Hospital for Chest Diseases, Puducherry, India.
Department of Microbiology, Jawaharlal Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education and Research, Puducherry, India.
Sci Rep. 2020 Oct 16;10(1):17552. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-74432-y.
India accounts for about one-fourth of the global burden of MDR-TB. This study aims to assess the prevalence and factors associated with tuberculosis drug resistance among patients from South India. MTBDRplus assay and MGIT liquid culture performed on 20,245 sputum specimens obtained from presumptive MDR-TB cases during a six-year period from 2013 to 2018 were analyzed retrospectively. Univariate and multivariate logistic regression analysis was carried out to evaluate factors associated with MDR, Rifampicin mono-resistance, and Isoniazid mono-resistance. MDR, Rifampicin mono- resistant and Isoniazid mono-resistant TB were found in 5.4%, 2.5%, and 11.4% cases of presumptive MDR-TB, respectively. Based on the rpoB gene, true resistance, hetero-resistance, and inferred resistance to Rifampicin was found in 38%, 29.3%, and 32.7% of the 1582 MDR cases, respectively. S450L (MUT3) was the most common rpoB mutation present in 59.4% of the Rifampicin resistant cases. Of the 3390 Isoniazid resistant cases, 72.5% had mutations in the katG gene, and 27.5% had mutations in the inhA gene. True resistance, heteroresistance, and inferred resistance accounted for 42.9%, 22.2%, and 17.3% of the 2459 katG resistant cases, respectively. True resistance, heteroresistance, and inferred resistance for the inhA gene were found in 54.5%, 40.7%, and 4.7% cases, respectively. MDR-contact (AOR 3.171 95% CI: 1.747-5.754, p-0.000) treatment failure (AOR 2.17595% CI: 1.703-2.777, p-0.000) and female gender (AOR 1.315 95% CI: 1.117-1.548, p-0.001), were positively associated with MDR-TB. Previous TB treatment did not show a significant positive association with MDR (AOR 1.113 95% CI: 0.801-1.546, p-0.523). Old age (AOR 0.994 95% CI: 0.990-0.999, p-0.023) and HIV seropositivity (AOR 0.580 95% CI: 0.369-0.911, p-0.018) were negatively associated with MDR-TB. Although Rifampicin mono-resistance had a positive association with treatment failure (AOR 2.509 95% CI: 1.804-3.490, p < .001), it did not show any association with previous TB treatment (AOR 1.286 95% CI: 0.765-2.164, p-0.342) or with history of contact with MDR-TB (AOR 1.813 95% CI: 0.591-5.560, p-0.298). However, INH mono-resistance showed a small positive association with the previous history of treatment for TB (AOR 1.303 95% CI: 1.021-1.662, p-0.033). It was also positively associated (AOR 2.094 95% CI: 1.236-3.548, p-0.006) with MDR-TB contacts. Thus INH resistance may develop during treatment if compliance has not adhered too and may be easily passed on to the contacts while Rifampicin resistance is probably due to factors other than treatment compliance. MDR-TB, i.e. resistance to both Rifampicin and Isoniazid, is strongly correlated with treatment failure, spread through contact, and not to treatment compliance. The temporal trend in this region shows a decrease in MDR prevalence from 8.4% in 2015 to 1.3% in 2018. A similar trend is observed for Rifampicin mono-resistance and Isoniazid mono-resistance, pointing to the effectiveness of the TB control program. The higher proportion of inferred resistance observed for Rifampicin compared with INH may indicate a surfeit of mechanisms that enable rifampicin resistance. Association of MDR-TB with age, gender, and HIV status suggest the role of the immune system in the emergence of the MDR phenotype.
印度约占全球耐多药结核病(MDR-TB)负担的四分之一。本研究旨在评估来自印度南部的患者中结核病药物耐药的流行情况和相关因素。对 2013 年至 2018 年六年期间从疑似 MDR-TB 病例中获得的 20,245 份痰标本进行 MTBDRplus 检测和 MGIT 液体培养,进行回顾性分析。采用单因素和多因素逻辑回归分析评估与 MDR、利福平单耐药和异烟肼单耐药相关的因素。疑似 MDR-TB 病例中,MDR、利福平单耐药和异烟肼单耐药分别为 5.4%、2.5%和 11.4%。基于 rpoB 基因,1582 例 MDR 病例中,真耐药、异源耐药和推测耐药的利福平耐药率分别为 38%、29.3%和 32.7%。S450L(MUT3)是 Rifampicin 耐药病例中最常见的 rpoB 突变,占 59.4%。3390 例异烟肼耐药病例中,72.5%的病例 katG 基因突变,27.5%的病例 inhA 基因突变。2459 例 katG 耐药病例中,真耐药、异源耐药和推测耐药分别占 42.9%、22.2%和 17.3%。inhA 基因的真耐药、异源耐药和推测耐药分别占 54.5%、40.7%和 4.7%。MDR 接触(AOR 3.171,95%CI:1.747-5.754,p-0.000)、治疗失败(AOR 2.175,95%CI:1.703-2.777,p-0.000)和女性(AOR 1.315,95%CI:1.117-1.548,p-0.001)与 MDR-TB 呈正相关。既往结核病治疗与 MDR 无显著正相关(AOR 1.113,95%CI:0.801-1.546,p-0.523)。年龄较大(AOR 0.994,95%CI:0.990-0.999,p-0.023)和 HIV 阳性(AOR 0.580,95%CI:0.369-0.911,p-0.018)与 MDR-TB 呈负相关。虽然利福平单耐药与治疗失败呈正相关(AOR 2.509,95%CI:1.804-3.490,p<0.001),但与既往结核病治疗(AOR 1.286,95%CI:0.765-2.164,p-0.342)或 MDR-TB 接触史(AOR 1.813,95%CI:0.591-5.560,p-0.298)无关。然而,INH 单耐药与既往结核病治疗史有一定的正相关(AOR 1.303,95%CI:1.021-1.662,p-0.033),并且与 MDR-TB 接触呈正相关(AOR 2.094,95%CI:1.236-3.548,p-0.006)。因此,如果依从性不佳,INH 耐药可能在治疗过程中发生,并且容易传播给接触者,而 Rifampicin 耐药可能是由于治疗依从性以外的因素引起的。MDR-TB,即利福平与异烟肼同时耐药,与治疗失败、接触传播密切相关,与治疗依从性无关。该地区的时间趋势显示,MDR 患病率从 2015 年的 8.4%下降到 2018 年的 1.3%。利福平单耐药和异烟肼单耐药也呈现出类似的趋势,表明结核病控制规划的有效性。与 INH 相比,Rifampicin 中推断耐药的比例较高可能表明存在大量使 Rifampicin 耐药的机制。MDR-TB 与年龄、性别和 HIV 状况相关,提示免疫系统在 MDR 表型的出现中起作用。