Department of Family Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Chiang Mai University, 110 Intharavoros Road, Chiang Mai, 50220, Thailand.
NCal Regional Ethics Department, Kaiser Permanente, Northern California, Oakland, CA, 94612, USA.
Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract. 2021 May;26(2):489-511. doi: 10.1007/s10459-020-09997-4. Epub 2020 Oct 19.
Correctional systems in several U.S. states have entered into partnerships with academic medical centers (AMCs) to provide healthcare for persons who are incarcerated. One AMC specializing in the care of incarcerated patients is the University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston (UTMB), which hosts the only dedicated prison hospital in the U.S. and supplies 80% of the medical care for the entire Texas Department of Criminal Justice (TDCJ). Nearly all medical students and residents at UTMB take part in the care of the incarcerated. This research, through qualitative exploration using focus group discussions, sets out to characterize the correctional care learning environment medical trainees enter. Participants outlined an institutional culture of low prioritization and neglect that dominated the learning environment in the prison hospital, resulting in treatment of the incarcerated as second-class patients. Medical learners pointed to delays in care, both within the prison hospital and within the TDCJ system, where diagnostic, laboratory, and medical procedures were delivered to incarcerated patients at a lower priority compared to free-world patients. Medical learners elaborated further on ethical issues that included the moral judgment of those who are incarcerated, bias in clinical decision making, and concerns for patient autonomy. Medical learners were left to grapple with complex challenges like the problem of dual loyalties without opportunities to critically reflect upon what they experienced. This study finds that, without specific vulnerable populations training for both trainees and correctional care faculty to address these institutional dynamics, AMCs risk replicating a system of exploitation and neglect of incarcerated patients and thereby exacerbating health inequities.
美国一些州的惩教系统已经与学术医疗中心 (AMC) 建立了合作关系,为被监禁的人提供医疗保健。德克萨斯大学加尔维斯顿医学分部 (UTMB) 是一家专门为被监禁患者提供护理的 AMC,它拥有美国唯一一家专门的监狱医院,并为整个德克萨斯州惩教部 (TDCJ) 提供 80%的医疗服务。UTMB 的几乎所有医学生和住院医师都参与了被监禁者的护理。这项研究通过使用焦点小组讨论进行定性探索,旨在描述医疗受训者进入的惩教护理学习环境的特点。参与者描述了一种低优先级和忽视的机构文化,这种文化主导了监狱医院的学习环境,导致被监禁者被视为二等病人。医疗学习者指出,在监狱医院和 TDCJ 系统内都存在护理延迟的问题,与自由世界的病人相比,对被监禁病人的诊断、实验室和医疗程序的处理优先级较低。医疗学习者进一步阐述了包括对被监禁者的道德判断、临床决策中的偏见以及对患者自主权的担忧在内的伦理问题。医疗学习者不得不应对一些复杂的挑战,比如双重忠诚的问题,而没有机会对他们所经历的事情进行批判性反思。这项研究发现,如果没有专门针对受训者和惩教护理教师的弱势群体培训来解决这些机构动态问题,AMC 可能会复制一种剥削和忽视被监禁患者的系统,从而加剧健康不平等。