Department of Anaesthesiology, Pain and Palliative Medicine.
Radboud University, Nijmegen, the Netherlands.
Br J Gen Pract. 2020 Oct 29;70(700):e833-e842. doi: 10.3399/bjgp20X713093. Print 2020 Nov.
Euthanasia has been regulated by law under strict conditions in the Netherlands since 2002. Since then the number of euthanasia cases has constantly increased, and increased exponentially for patients with dementia (PWD). The number of euthanasia requests by such patients is even higher. Recently, an interview study showed that physicians who are confronted with a PWD's euthanasia request experience problems with communication, pressure from relatives, patients, and society, workload, interpretation of the law, and ethical considerations. Moreover, if honoured, the physician and patient may interpret the right moment for euthanasia differently.
To identify ways of supporting GPs confronted with a PWD's euthanasia request.
Two expert nominal group meetings were organised with Dutch care physicians for older people, GPs, legal experts, a healthcare chaplain, a palliative care consultant, and a psychologist.
A total of 15 experts participated in the meetings. Both meetings were audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim, and analysed using thematic analysis.
Four themes emerged from the meetings: support provided by healthcare professionals, influencing public opinion, educational activities, and managing time and work pressure. The need for support was considered highest for GPs for all of these themes.
Consensus was reached with the help of experts on support needs for GPs confronted with euthanasia requests from PWD. A concise and clear explanation of the law is strongly desired. Changing public opinion seems the most challenging and a long-term aim. Communication training for finding the right balance between the physician's professional responsibility and the patient's autonomy should be made available, as a short-term aim.
自 2002 年以来,荷兰在严格的条件下将安乐死合法化。从那时起,安乐死的案例数量不断增加,痴呆症患者(PWD)的安乐死案例呈指数级增长。此类患者的安乐死请求数量甚至更高。最近,一项访谈研究表明,面对 PWD 的安乐死请求,医生在沟通、亲属、患者和社会的压力、工作量、对法律的解释和伦理考虑方面存在问题。此外,如果同意,医生和患者可能对安乐死的合适时机有不同的解释。
确定支持面对 PWD 安乐死请求的全科医生的方法。
与荷兰老年护理医生、全科医生、法律专家、医疗牧师、姑息治疗顾问和心理学家一起组织了两次专家名义小组会议。
共有 15 名专家参加了会议。两次会议都进行了录音、逐字转录,并使用主题分析进行了分析。
会议产生了四个主题:医疗保健专业人员提供的支持、影响公众舆论、教育活动以及管理时间和工作压力。对于所有这些主题,全科医生对支持的需求被认为是最高的。
在专家的帮助下,就面对 PWD 安乐死请求的全科医生的支持需求达成了共识。强烈希望对法律进行简明清晰的解释。改变公众舆论似乎是最具挑战性的,也是一个长期目标。应该提供寻找医生的专业责任和患者自主权之间适当平衡的沟通培训,作为短期目标。