Ma Yue, Zhang Xinwu, Li Haoyang, Ma Xiaochen, Friesen Dimitris, Rozelle Scott, Pang Xiaopeng, Zhou Ming, Congdon Nathan
Rural Education Action Program, Stanford University Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies, Stanford, California, USA.
School of Public Administration, Northwest University, Xi'an, Shaanxi, China.
BMJ Open Ophthalmol. 2020 Sep 30;5(1):e000572. doi: 10.1136/bmjophth-2020-000572. eCollection 2020.
To assess the effect of free eyeglasses provision on visual acuity among middle school students in northwestern rural China.
Among 31 middle schools randomly selected from 47 middle schools in northwestern rural China, students were randomly allocated by school to one of two interventions: free eyeglasses (intervention group), and eyeglasses prescriptions given only to the parents (control group). The main outcome of this study is uncorrected visual acuity after 9 months, adjusted for baseline visual acuity.
Among 2095 students from 31 middle schools, 995 (47.5%) failed the visual acuity screening, 515 (51.8%, 15 schools) of which were randomly assigned to the intervention group, with the remaining 480 students (48.2%, 16 schools) assigned to the control group. Among these, a total of 910 students were followed up and analysed. Endline eyeglasses wear in the intervention group was 44%, and 36% in the control group. Endline visual acuity of students in the intervention group was significantly better than students in the control group, adjusting for other variables (0.045 LogMAR units, 95% CI 0.006 to 0.084, equivalent to 0.45 lines, p=0.027), and insignificantly better only for baseline visual acuity (difference of 0.008 LogMAR units, 95% CI -0.018 to 0.034, equivalent to 0.08 lines).
We found no evidence that receiving free eyeglasses worsened visual acuity among middle school students in northwestern rural China.
ISRCTN17141957.
评估在中国西北农村地区为中学生免费提供眼镜对视力的影响。
从中国西北农村地区47所中学中随机选取31所中学,学生按学校随机分配至两种干预措施之一:免费眼镜(干预组),仅向家长提供眼镜处方(对照组)。本研究的主要结局是9个月后的未矫正视力,并根据基线视力进行调整。
在31所中学的2095名学生中,995名(47.5%)视力筛查未通过,其中515名(51.8%,15所学校)被随机分配至干预组,其余480名学生(48.2%,16所学校)被分配至对照组。其中,共有910名学生接受随访并进行分析。干预组最终佩戴眼镜的比例为44%,对照组为36%。在调整其他变量后,干预组学生的最终视力显著优于对照组(0.045 LogMAR单位,95%可信区间0.006至0.084,相当于0.45行,p = 0.027),仅对于基线视力改善不显著(差异为0.008 LogMAR单位,95%可信区间-0.018至0.034,相当于0.08行)。
我们没有发现证据表明在中国西北农村地区,中学生接受免费眼镜会使视力变差。
ISRCTN17141957。