Umana Giuseppe Emmanuele, Scalia Gianluca, Chaurasia Bipin, Fricia Marco, Passanisi Maurizio, Graziano Francesca, Nicoletti Giovanni Federico, Cicero Salvatore
Department of Neurosurgery, Trauma Center, Gamma Knife Center, Cannizzaro Hospital, Catania, Italy.
Neurosurgery Unit, Highly Specialized Hospital and of National Importance "Garibaldi", Catania, Italy.
J Craniovertebr Junction Spine. 2020 Jul-Sep;11(3):157-162. doi: 10.4103/jcvjs.JCVJS_106_20. Epub 2020 Aug 14.
Perimedullary arteriovenous fistulas (PMAVFs) are uncommon vascular malformations, and they rarely occur at the level of the craniovertebral junction (CVJ). The therapeutic management is challenging and can include observation alone, endovascular occlusion, or surgical exclusion, depending on both patient and malformation characteristics. A systematic literature search was conducted using MEDLINE, Scopus, and Google Scholar databases, searching for the following combined MeSH terms: . We also present an emblematic case of PMAVF at the level of the craniovertebral junction associated to a venous pseudoaneurysm. A total of 31 published studies were identified; 10 were rejected from our review because they did not match our inclusion criteria. Our case was not included in the systematic review. We selected 21 studies for this systematic review with a total of 58 patients, including 20 females (34.5%) and 38 males (65.5%), with a female/male ratio of 1:1.9. Thirty-nine out of 58 patients underwent surgical treatment (67.2%), 15 out of 58 patients were treated with endovascular approach (25.8%), 3 out of 58 patients underwent combined treatment (5.2%), and only 1 patient was managed conservatively (1.7%). An improved outcome was reported in 94.8% of cases (55 out of 58 patients), whereas 3 out of 58 patients (5.2%) were moderately disabled after surgery and endovascular treatment. In literature, hemorrhagic presentation is reported as the most common onset (subarachnoid hemorrhage in 63% and intramedullary hemorrhage in 10%), frequently caused either by venous dilation, due to an ascending drainage pathway into an intracranial vein, or by the higher venous flow rates that can be associated with intracranial drainage. Hiramatsu and Sato stated that arterial feeders from the anterior spinal artery (ASA) and aneurysmal dilations are associated with hemorrhagic presentation. In agreement with the classification by Hiramatsu, we defined the PMAVF of the CVJ as a vascular lesion fed by the radiculomeningeal arteries from the vertebral artery and the spinal pial arteries from the ASA and/or lateral spinal artery. Considering the anatomical characteristics, we referred to our patient as affected by PMAVF, even if it was difficult to precisely localize the arteriovenous shunts because of the complex angioarchitecture of the fine feeding arteries and draining veins, but we presumed that the shunt was located in the point of major difference in vessel size between the feeding arteries and draining veins. PMAVFs of CVJ are rare pathologies of challenging management. The best diagnostic workup and treatment are still controversial: more studies are needed to compare different therapeutic strategies concerning both long-term occlusion rates and outcomes.
髓周动静脉瘘(PMAVF)是一种罕见的血管畸形,很少发生在颅颈交界区(CVJ)。其治疗管理具有挑战性,根据患者和畸形的特征,治疗方法可包括单纯观察、血管内闭塞或手术切除。我们使用MEDLINE、Scopus和谷歌学术数据库进行了系统的文献检索,搜索以下组合的医学主题词: 。我们还展示了一例发生在颅颈交界区并伴有静脉假性动脉瘤的典型PMAVF病例。共识别出31项已发表的研究;其中10项因不符合纳入标准而被排除在我们的综述之外。我们的病例未纳入该系统评价。我们选择了21项研究进行该系统评价,共有58例患者,其中女性20例(34.5%),男性38例(65.5%),男女比例为1:1.9。58例患者中有39例接受了手术治疗(67.2%),58例患者中有15例采用血管内治疗(25.8%),58例患者中有3例接受了联合治疗(5.2%),只有1例患者采用保守治疗(1.7%)。94.8%的病例(58例患者中的55例)报告预后改善,而58例患者中有3例(5.2%)在手术和血管内治疗后有中度残疾。在文献中,出血表现被报道为最常见的发病形式(蛛网膜下腔出血占63%,髓内出血占10%),这通常是由于静脉扩张所致,原因是引流途径向上进入颅内静脉,或者是由于与颅内引流相关的较高静脉血流速度。Hiramatsu和Sato指出,来自脊髓前动脉(ASA)的动脉供血支和动脉瘤样扩张与出血表现有关。与Hiramatsu的分类一致,我们将CVJ的PMAVF定义为由椎动脉的神经根脑膜动脉以及ASA和/或脊髓外侧动脉的脊髓软膜动脉供血的血管病变。考虑到解剖学特征,尽管由于精细供血动脉和引流静脉的复杂血管结构难以精确确定动静脉分流的位置,但我们仍将我们的患者诊断为PMAVF,我们推测分流位于供血动脉和引流静脉在血管大小上差异最大的部位。CVJ的PMAVF是管理具有挑战性的罕见病变。最佳的诊断检查和治疗仍存在争议:需要更多的研究来比较不同治疗策略在长期闭塞率和预后方面的差异。