Bhavnani Suresh K, Dang Bryant, Penton Rebekah, Visweswaran Shyam, Bassler Kevin E, Chen Tianlong, Raji Mukaila, Divekar Rohit, Zuhour Raed, Karmarkar Amol, Kuo Yong-Fang, Ottenbacher Kenneth J
Preventive Medicine and Population Health, University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, TX, United States.
Institute for Translational Sciences, University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, TX, United States.
JMIR Med Inform. 2020 Oct 26;8(10):e13567. doi: 10.2196/13567.
When older adult patients with hip fracture (HFx) have unplanned hospital readmissions within 30 days of discharge, it doubles their 1-year mortality, resulting in substantial personal and financial burdens. Although such unplanned readmissions are predominantly caused by reasons not related to HFx surgery, few studies have focused on how pre-existing high-risk comorbidities co-occur within and across subgroups of patients with HFx.
This study aims to use a combination of supervised and unsupervised visual analytical methods to (1) obtain an integrated understanding of comorbidity risk, comorbidity co-occurrence, and patient subgroups, and (2) enable a team of clinical and methodological stakeholders to infer the processes that precipitate unplanned hospital readmission, with the goal of designing targeted interventions.
We extracted a training data set consisting of 16,886 patients (8443 readmitted patients with HFx and 8443 matched controls) and a replication data set consisting of 16,222 patients (8111 readmitted patients with HFx and 8111 matched controls) from the 2010 and 2009 Medicare database, respectively. The analyses consisted of a supervised combinatorial analysis to identify and replicate combinations of comorbidities that conferred significant risk for readmission, an unsupervised bipartite network analysis to identify and replicate how high-risk comorbidity combinations co-occur across readmitted patients with HFx, and an integrated visualization and analysis of comorbidity risk, comorbidity co-occurrence, and patient subgroups to enable clinician stakeholders to infer the processes that precipitate readmission in patient subgroups and to propose targeted interventions.
The analyses helped to identify (1) 11 comorbidity combinations that conferred significantly higher risk (ranging from P<.001 to P=.01) for a 30-day readmission, (2) 7 biclusters of patients and comorbidities with a significant bicluster modularity (P<.001; Medicare=0.440; random mean 0.383 [0.002]), indicating strong heterogeneity in the comorbidity profiles of readmitted patients, and (3) inter- and intracluster risk associations, which enabled clinician stakeholders to infer the processes involved in the exacerbation of specific combinations of comorbidities leading to readmission in patient subgroups.
The integrated analysis of risk, co-occurrence, and patient subgroups enabled the inference of processes that precipitate readmission, leading to a comorbidity exacerbation risk model for readmission after HFx. These results have direct implications for (1) the management of comorbidities targeted at high-risk subgroups of patients with the goal of pre-emptively reducing their risk of readmission and (2) the development of more accurate risk prediction models that incorporate information about patient subgroups.
老年髋部骨折(HFx)患者在出院后30天内出现非计划的医院再入院情况时,其1年死亡率会翻倍,从而带来巨大的个人和经济负担。尽管此类非计划再入院主要由与HFx手术无关的原因引起,但很少有研究关注HFx患者亚组内部和之间预先存在的高风险合并症是如何同时出现的。
本研究旨在结合使用监督式和非监督式视觉分析方法,以(1)全面了解合并症风险、合并症同时出现的情况以及患者亚组,(2)使临床和方法学相关利益者团队能够推断出导致非计划医院再入院的过程,目标是设计有针对性的干预措施。
我们分别从2010年和2009年的医疗保险数据库中提取了一个由16,886名患者组成的训练数据集(8443名HFx再入院患者和8443名匹配对照)以及一个由16,222名患者组成的复制数据集(8111名HFx再入院患者和8111名匹配对照)。分析包括监督式组合分析,以识别和复制赋予再入院显著风险的合并症组合;非监督式二分网络分析,以识别和复制高风险合并症组合在HFx再入院患者中的同时出现情况;以及对合并症风险、合并症同时出现情况和患者亚组进行综合可视化和分析,以使临床相关利益者能够推断出导致患者亚组再入院的过程,并提出有针对性的干预措施。
分析有助于识别出(1)11种合并症组合,这些组合赋予30天再入院的风险显著更高(范围从P<0.001到P = 0.01);(2)7个患者和合并症的双聚类,具有显著的双聚类模块性(P<0.001;医疗保险=
0.440;随机均值0.383 [0.002]),表明再入院患者的合并症概况存在强烈异质性;以及(3)聚类间和聚类内的风险关联,这使临床相关利益者能够推断出导致特定合并症组合加重并导致患者亚组再入院的过程。
对风险、同时出现情况和患者亚组的综合分析能够推断出导致再入院的过程,从而得出HFx后再入院的合并症加重风险模型。这些结果对(1)针对高风险患者亚组的合并症管理具有直接意义,目标是预先降低他们的再入院风险;(2)开发纳入患者亚组信息的更准确风险预测模型具有直接意义。