Wiener F, Gabbai M, Jaffe M
Faculty of Medicine, Technion, Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa.
Comput Biol Med. 1987;17(4):259-67. doi: 10.1016/0010-4825(87)90012-6.
The diagnostic classification of children with dysmorphic features involves over 200 syndromes and 232 findings, with an average of about 15 findings per syndrome. A knowledge base expressed in terms of Boolean combinations of findings is impractical. The normal Bayesian method requires a very large incidence matrix with the vast majority of cells being zero. A modified Bayesian method is proposed in which each syndrome is described in terms of its associated findings, whose incidence P (S/D) are designated as essential (0.90), prevalent (0.90), occasional (0.70) or rare (0.15), whilst P(S/-D) ranged from (0.08) to (0.10). The Bayesian calculation determines the probability of the presence P(D/S) or the absence P(-D/S) of each syndrome. The differential diagnosis consisted of all syndromes whose presence has a probability greater than 0.85. One hundred and thirty-one cases from the Hanna Khoushi Developmental Pediatrics Center at Haifa's Rothschild Hospital were considered. Of the 42 cases for which the center's specialists reached a diagnosis, the system listed the correct diagnosis for 91%. The system reached a diagnosis in about half of the remaining 89 cases. The medical literature is arranged by syndrome whilst the computer allows a case by case approach, thereby avoiding the need for the physician to consider each syndrome to see if it fits his case. This study shows that our modified Bayesian analysis is a valid method for shortening the physician's search in an area of great diagnostic complexity.
患有畸形特征儿童的诊断分类涉及200多种综合征和232项体征,平均每种综合征约有15项体征。用体征的布尔组合来表示知识库是不切实际的。传统的贝叶斯方法需要一个非常大的发病率矩阵,其中绝大多数单元格为零。本文提出了一种改进的贝叶斯方法,其中每个综合征都根据其相关体征进行描述,这些体征的发病率P(S/D)被指定为基本的(0.90)、常见的(0.90)、偶发的(0.70)或罕见的(0.15),而P(S/-D)范围为(0.08)至(0.10)。贝叶斯计算确定每种综合征存在P(D/S)或不存在P(-D/S)的概率。鉴别诊断包括所有存在概率大于0.85的综合征。研究考虑了海法罗斯柴尔德医院汉娜·胡什发育儿科中心的131例病例。在该中心专家做出诊断的42例病例中,系统列出正确诊断的比例为91%。在其余89例病例中,系统约对一半病例做出了诊断。医学文献是按综合征编排的,而计算机允许逐例分析,从而避免医生逐一考虑每种综合征以确定其是否符合病例的需要。这项研究表明,我们改进的贝叶斯分析是一种有效的方法,可缩短医生在诊断复杂性高的领域中的搜索时间。