Beyene Deginet, Abuye Habtamu, Tilahun Gizachew
Pharmaceutical Supply Chain Management, Pharmacy Department Unit, Doctor Bogalech Gebre Memorial General Hospital, Durame, Ethiopia.
Department of Pharmacy, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, Wachemo University, Hosaena, Ethiopia.
Integr Pharm Res Pract. 2020 Oct 13;9:185-194. doi: 10.2147/IPRP.S277080. eCollection 2020.
Auditable pharmaceuticals service and transaction system (APTS) is unique in its systems strengthening approach. It is a data-driven package of interventions designed to establish accountable, transparent, and responsible pharmacy practice. The objective of this study was to assess the outcome performance of pharmaceuticals services among selected hospitals with and without the APTS system in SNNPR, Ethiopia.
A cross-sectional comparative facility-based study was conducted at public hospitals by using an intervention and control approach to estimate the significance of the difference between average performances of APTS and non-APTS hospitals. A case-to-control ratio was applied to decide the number of sites and a simple random lottery sampling technique was employed to select control sites. The sample size formula was used to determine the proposed population for patient care indicator assessment. Epidata version 3.1 and SPSS version 23 were used for analysis. The study was conducted from March 1 to 30, 2019.
APTS implemented hospitals attained 92.3% patient satisfaction on the overall pharmacy services compared to 47.5% for non-APTS hospitals. They have improved essential drugs (EDs) availability, minimum stock-outs, and reduced wastage rates, unlike control groups. They undertook workload analysis to assess human power sufficiency; generate reliable information from accurate recording culture for decision making; practiced transparency and accountability through conducting physical inventory and daily sales tracking/management system; and made budget utilization rationale applying ABC analysis, VEN analysis, ABC/VEN reconciliation, and stock status analysis (SSA) that non-APTS hospitals did less/not.
In general, higher performances were observed in APTS implemented hospitals than non-APTS hospitals regarding patient knowledge, satisfaction, and medicine availability at stores. In all cases, it needs improvement to achieve target values.
可审计药品服务与交易系统(APTS)在其系统强化方法上独具特色。它是一套以数据为驱动的干预措施组合,旨在建立可问责、透明且负责的药房实践。本研究的目的是评估埃塞俄比亚南方各族州人民区域州(SNNPR)中采用和未采用APTS系统的选定医院的药品服务成果表现。
采用干预与对照方法,在公立医院开展了一项基于机构的横断面比较研究,以估算APTS医院和非APTS医院平均表现之间差异的显著性。采用病例对照比来确定研究地点数量,并采用简单随机抽签抽样技术选择对照地点。样本量公式用于确定拟评估患者护理指标的总体人群。使用Epidata 3.1版和SPSS 23版进行分析。研究于2019年3月1日至30日进行。
实施APTS的医院在整体药房服务方面患者满意度达到92.3%,而非APTS医院为47.5%。与对照组不同,它们提高了基本药物(EDs)的可及性,减少了缺货情况,并降低了浪费率。它们进行工作量分析以评估人力充足性;通过准确的记录文化生成可靠信息用于决策;通过进行实物盘点和日常销售跟踪/管理系统实现透明度和问责制;并运用ABC分析、VEN分析、ABC/VEN核对以及库存状态分析(SSA)来进行预算使用合理性分析,而非APTS医院较少/未进行这些操作。
总体而言,在患者知识、满意度以及药房药品可及性方面,实施APTS的医院比非APTS医院表现更佳。在所有情况下,都需要改进以达到目标值。