Guthier Christina, Dormann Christian, Voelkle Manuel C
Johannes Gutenberg-University.
Humboldt-Universitat zu Berlin.
Psychol Bull. 2020 Dec;146(12):1146-1173. doi: 10.1037/bul0000304. Epub 2020 Oct 29.
Results from longitudinal studies are ambiguous regarding the direction of effects between job stressors and burnout over time. We meta-analyzed possible reciprocal relations between job stressors and burnout in = 48 longitudinal studies ( = 26,319), accounting for variation of time intervals in primary studies by using continuous time meta-analysis. Additionally, we analyzed whether country-level job resources (job control and job support; = 31 European studies, = 17,747) moderated the effect of job stressors on burnout (stressor-effect) and the effect of burnout on job stressors (strain-effect). Further, we analyzed the replicability of the primary studies by assessing between-study heterogeneity, publication bias, and statistical power. Reciprocal effects between job stressors and burnout exist. The stressor-effect is small, whereas the strain-effect is larger and moderated by job control and job support. Analyses of the different burnout symptoms (emotional) exhaustion and depersonalization/cynicism demonstrated that reciprocal relations between emotional exhaustion and job stressors exist, but depersonalization/cynicism is not directly related to job stressors. Between-study heterogeneity was comparable with other psychological studies, whereas statistical power of primary studies was comparatively large. Conclusions are limited because few primary studies used time intervals of less than 12 months, more than two measurement occasions, and objective measures of stressors. Overall, results imply the need for extended job stress models and new job stress interventions that help employees cope with burnout symptoms. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2020 APA, all rights reserved).
纵向研究的结果对于工作压力源与倦怠之间随时间变化的影响方向并不明确。我们对48项纵向研究(N = 26,319)中工作压力源与倦怠之间可能的相互关系进行了元分析,通过使用连续时间元分析来考虑原始研究中时间间隔的差异。此外,我们分析了国家层面的工作资源(工作控制和工作支持;31项欧洲研究,N = 17,747)是否调节了工作压力源对倦怠的影响(压力源效应)以及倦怠对工作压力源的影响(应变效应)。此外,我们通过评估研究间异质性、发表偏倚和统计功效来分析原始研究的可重复性。工作压力源与倦怠之间存在相互影响。压力源效应较小,而应变效应较大,并且受到工作控制和工作支持的调节。对不同倦怠症状(情感耗竭和去个性化/玩世不恭)的分析表明,情感耗竭与工作压力源之间存在相互关系,但去个性化/玩世不恭与工作压力源没有直接关系。研究间异质性与其他心理学研究相当,而原始研究的统计功效相对较大。由于很少有原始研究使用少于12个月的时间间隔、超过两次的测量时机以及压力源的客观测量方法,因此结论有限。总体而言,结果表明需要扩展工作压力模型和新的工作压力干预措施,以帮助员工应对倦怠症状。(PsycInfo数据库记录(c)2020美国心理学会,保留所有权利)