Vesselinov Elena
Department of Sociology, Queens College and The Graduate Center, City University of New York.
Sociol Compass. 2010 Nov;4(11):989-998. doi: 10.1111/j.1751-9020.2010.00330.x. Epub 2010 Nov 5.
Scholarly research about gated communities is a recently established field of study, because the significant proliferation of these communities has occurred in the last couple of decades. In this article, I argue that the seminal work of Blakely and Snyder (1997, . Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution Press.) gave the first impetus and the initial research directions in gated communities' study. The subsequent research established it as a true interdisciplinary urban field and produced important knowledge across several different academic disciplines: sociology, political science, anthropology, urban policy and planning, geography, and legal studies. The article discusses this first phase of theoretical and empirical work, based mostly on qualitative and secondary data sources. A new methodological shift is proposed, which should determine the second phase of research based on hypotheses testing and collection of systematic empirical evidence. Such evidence is essential to understand the wider impact of gated communities on larger urban areas and society as a whole.
关于封闭社区的学术研究是一个最近才建立的研究领域,因为这些社区在过去几十年中显著增多。在本文中,我认为布莱克利和斯奈德(1997年,华盛顿特区:布鲁金斯学会出版社)的开创性著作首次推动了封闭社区研究并给出了初步研究方向。随后的研究将其确立为一个真正的跨学科城市领域,并在多个不同学术学科中产生了重要知识:社会学、政治学、人类学、城市政策与规划、地理学以及法律研究。本文讨论了这一主要基于定性和二手数据源的理论与实证研究的第一阶段。文中提出了一种新的方法论转变,它应基于假设检验和系统实证证据的收集来确定研究的第二阶段。此类证据对于理解封闭社区对更大城市区域乃至整个社会的更广泛影响至关重要。