Department of Health and Human Developmen, Health and Human Development, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States.
Affairs Council of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States.
Int Q Community Health Educ. 2021 Jul;41(4):411-418. doi: 10.1177/0272684X20970375. Epub 2020 Nov 3.
Latino preschool children have higher rates of obesity than children from other racial/ethnic backgrounds. Few effective, culturally-tailored obesity prevention interventions exist that have focused on Latino preschool children, and even fewer have published results of the process evaluation. The purpose of this paper was to monitor reach, fidelity, and completeness of implementation to determine whether ANDALE, a promising -led, home-based pilot study to prevent obesity in Latino preschool children, was implemented as planned.
Guided by a logic model, we assessed reach, implementation fidelity and completeness through descriptive analyses of multiple data sources. Reach was assessed through attendance records. Fidelity was assessed via observation checklist and completeness was assessed via survey with both parents and in a subsample of 12 families.
recruited participants primarily through their own social networks and delivered the intervention to 50 families (mother-child dyads); the majority were of Mexican-origin, low-acculturation, dual-parent households. Nearly all (98%) families completed the whole 10-week intervention. Results demonstrated completeness and fidelity of implementation were acceptable in a subsample of 12 families. In sum, 75% of families in the subsample met the criteria (≥75%) for overall implementation of essential program elements (i.e., reach, completeness, and fidelity).
Evidence suggests that ANDALE was delivered with high levels of completeness and fidelity in this sample of Latino families with preschool-aged children. These results support implementation of ANDALE in a large, randomized trial.
拉丁裔学龄前儿童的肥胖率高于其他种族/族裔背景的儿童。针对拉丁裔学龄前儿童的有效、文化适应性强的肥胖预防干预措施很少,而且很少有研究公布其过程评估结果。本文的目的是监测参与度、实施的保真度和完整性,以确定 ANDALE 是否按计划实施,这是一项针对拉丁裔学龄前儿童的有前途的以家庭为基础的预防肥胖的试点研究。
本研究以逻辑模型为指导,通过对多种数据源的描述性分析来评估参与度、实施保真度和完整性。通过出席记录评估参与度。通过观察检查表评估保真度,通过对所有父母和 12 个家庭中的一个子样本进行调查评估完整性。
研究通过参与者自身的社交网络招募了 50 个家庭(母子二人组);大多数家庭的父母都是墨西哥裔,低同化,双亲家庭。几乎所有(98%)家庭都完成了整个 10 周的干预。结果表明,在 12 个家庭的子样本中,实施的完整性和保真度是可以接受的。总体而言,子样本中 75%的家庭符合(≥75%)整体实施基本项目要素的标准(即参与度、完整性和保真度)。
有证据表明,在这个有学龄前儿童的拉丁裔家庭样本中,ANDALE 的实施具有高度的完整性和保真度。这些结果支持在大规模随机试验中实施 ANDALE。