Lane Suzie, Ayeb-Karlsson Sonja, Shahvisi Arianne
Global Health, Brighton and Sussex Medical School, Brighton, UK.
Environment and Migration: Interactions and Choices section, United Nations University Institute for Environment and Human Security, Bonn, Germany.
Glob Public Health. 2021 Dec;16(12):1804-1819. doi: 10.1080/17441692.2020.1840611. Epub 2020 Nov 5.
The Global Gag Rule is a United States policy that blocks global health funding to foreign non-governmental organisations if they engage in abortion-related activities. It has been implemented by every Republican administration since 1984 and remains in operation at the time of writing in its most stringent and extensive form. It has been criticised for its implications for women's bodily autonomy, its censorship of non-governmental organisations and health professionals, and for its impact on the health of populations in affected countries. To capture the effects of the policy to date, we conducted a scoping review in April 2020. Forty-eight articles met our eligibility criteria, and were analysed thematically, noting the effects on: the operations of non-governmental organisations; maternal health; sexually transmitted infections; marginalised groups; reproductive rights. We found that the policy increased the abortion rate and had a negative impact on maternal health, STIs, and the health of marginalised groups. We conclude that the policy amounts to the neocolonial co-optation of sexual and reproductive health in the Global South to advance an ideological agenda in the Global North. We urge that the policy be repealed as part of the broader project of protecting and decolonising sexual and reproductive health globally.
“全球禁言规则”是美国的一项政策,该政策规定,如果外国非政府组织从事与堕胎相关的活动,将阻止向其提供全球卫生资金。自1984年以来,每届共和党政府都实施了这一政策,在撰写本文时,它仍以最严格、最广泛的形式实施。该政策因其对女性身体自主权的影响、对非政府组织和卫生专业人员的审查以及对受影响国家民众健康的影响而受到批评。为了了解该政策迄今为止的影响,我们在2020年4月进行了一次范围审查。48篇文章符合我们的纳入标准,并进行了主题分析,记录了对以下方面的影响:非政府组织的运作;孕产妇健康;性传播感染;边缘化群体;生殖权利。我们发现,该政策提高了堕胎率,并对孕产妇健康、性传播感染以及边缘化群体的健康产生了负面影响。我们得出结论,该政策相当于对全球南方性与生殖健康的新殖民主义利用,以推进全球北方的意识形态议程。我们敦促废除该政策,作为全球保护和使性与生殖健康非殖民化这一更广泛项目的一部分。