Ribeiro Joana Fernandes, Rosete Manuel, Teixeira Andreia, Conceição Hugo, Santos Lèlita
Medicina Geral e Familiar. Unidade de Saúde Familiar Faria Guimarães. Agrupamentos de Centros de Saúde Porto Oriental. Porto. Portugal.
Serviço de Cirurgia Geral. Centro Hospitalar e Universitário de Coimbra. Coimbra. Portugal.
Acta Med Port. 2020 Nov 2;33(11):742-752. doi: 10.20344/amp.12125.
Technical skills training is fundamental for clinical practice although poorly emphasised in undergraduate medical curricula. In these circumstances, Peer Assisted Learning methodology has emerged as a valid alternative to overcome this insufficiency. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the impact on students of a Peer Assisted Learning program in basic surgical skills, regarding technical competences and knowledge improvement.
A total of 104 randomly selected third year medical students participated in a workshop delivered by fifth year students. From that total, 34 students were assessed before and after the workshop, using the Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills instrument, that consists of a global rating scale and a procedure-specific checklist. Sixth year students (control group) were also assessed in their performance without participating in the workshop. Before workshop versus after workshop Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills results were compared using Wilcoxon and McNemar tests. After workshop versus control group Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills results were compared using Mann-Whitney, qui-squared test and Fisher's exact test.
For the global rating scale, students obtained an after the workshop score (29.5) that was significantly higher than the before the workshop score (15.5; p-value < 0.001), but no significant differences were found between after the workshop and control group scores (p-value = 0.167). For the procedure-specific checklist, 3rd year students had a substantial positive evolution in all parameters and obtained higher rates of correct achievements compared to the control group.
The final outcomes demonstrated a significant qualitative and quantitative improvement of knowledge and technical skills, which is in accordance with other literature.
This Peer Assisted Learning program revealed promising results concerning improvement of surgical skills in medical students, with little staff faculty contribution and extension to a much broader number of students.
技术技能培训是临床实践的基础,尽管在本科医学课程中未得到充分重视。在这种情况下,同伴辅助学习方法已成为克服这一不足的有效替代方案。本研究的目的是评估同伴辅助学习计划对医学生基本外科技能的影响,包括技术能力和知识提升方面。
总共104名随机挑选的三年级医学生参加了由五年级学生举办的研讨会。其中34名学生在研讨会前后使用客观结构化技术技能评估工具进行评估,该工具包括一个整体评分量表和一个特定程序清单。六年级学生(对照组)也在未参加研讨会的情况下接受了技能表现评估。使用Wilcoxon和McNemar检验比较研讨会前与研讨会后客观结构化技术技能评估结果。使用Mann-Whitney、卡方检验和Fisher精确检验比较研讨会后与对照组客观结构化技术技能评估结果。
对于整体评分量表,学生在研讨会后的得分(29.5)显著高于研讨会前的得分(15.5;p值<0.001),但研讨会后得分与对照组得分之间未发现显著差异(p值=0.167)。对于特定程序清单,三年级学生在所有参数上都有显著的积极进步,与对照组相比,正确完成率更高。
最终结果表明,知识和技术技能在质量和数量上都有显著提高,这与其他文献一致。
该同伴辅助学习计划在提高医学生外科技能方面显示出有希望的结果,所需教师投入少,并能惠及更多学生。