Lauro Grein Filho Center for Otorhinolaryngological Studies.
Lauro Grein Filho Center for Otorhinolaryngological Studies; Positivo University; Postgraduate Program in Communication Disorders, Tuiuti do Paraná University; Brazilian Red Cross Hospital, Paraná, Brazil.
J Voice. 2023 Jan;37(1):141.e13-141.e21. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2020.10.014. Epub 2020 Nov 2.
Videolaryngoscopy screening is essential to help assessing human larynx. The use of 70° optical fiber in association with image recording by analog or digital cameras is one of the methods adopted to perform this examination. Endoscopic exams can contaminate the equipment with several microorganisms. The pandemic caused by the new coronavirus reinforces the importance of developing efficient barrier methods to be adopted in videolaryngoscopy procedures. Although dental intraoral camera covers are a barrier method authorized by Brazilian health organs, it has not yet been used in videolaryngoscopy examinations. The aim of the current longitudinal, individualized, single-blind, prospective, self-controlled, and accurate study is to evaluate the quality of images generated through, and confidence level of, diagnosis based on videolaryngoscopy performed with intraoral dental camera equipped with disposable protection cap and connected to 70° rigid laryngoscope in vocally healthy individuals. Videolaryngoscopy examinations based on 70° rigid optics were performed in 13 euphonic and asymptomatic volunteers at an otorhinolaryngology specialist clinic; only 1 patient was excluded from the study. Images were taken with, and without, disposable intraoral dental camera protection cap; high-grade disinfection protocol was applied between examinations. Recorded videos were randomly distributed in a single-blind manner in order to be evaluated by four otorhinolaryngologists, who answered a questionnaire comprising three questions. Statistical analysis was used to compare groups - which were defined by the use, or not, of protection cap - based on Wilcoxon nonparametric test. Statistical significance was set at 5% with 95% confidence interval. There was no statistically significant difference in image quality between examinations performed with, and without, protection cap (P= 0.646) or in the diagnosis confidence level of examinations performed with, or without, the barrier method. The use of disposable protection cap on intraoral dental camera did not significantly change the quality of images taken through videolaryngoscopy performed with 70° rigid optics in vocally healthy patients.
视频喉镜检查对于评估人类喉部至关重要。使用 70°光纤结合模拟或数字摄像头进行图像记录是进行此项检查的方法之一。内窥镜检查会使设备受到多种微生物的污染。新冠病毒大流行凸显了开发在视频喉镜检查中采用的有效屏障方法的重要性。虽然口腔内牙科相机盖是巴西卫生机构授权的一种屏障方法,但它尚未在视频喉镜检查中使用。本研究为一项纵向、个体化、单盲、前瞻性、自身对照和精确的研究,旨在评估在声音健康个体中进行的配备一次性保护套的口腔内牙科相机和连接至 70°刚性喉镜的视频喉镜检查所生成图像的质量和基于该检查的诊断置信度。在耳鼻喉科专家诊所对 13 名发音清晰且无症状的志愿者进行了基于 70°刚性光学的视频喉镜检查;只有 1 名患者被排除在研究之外。检查时使用和不使用一次性口腔内牙科相机保护盖进行拍摄;检查之间应用高级别消毒方案。记录的视频以单盲方式随机分配,由四位耳鼻喉科医生进行评估,他们回答了包含三个问题的问卷。统计分析用于比较使用和不使用保护盖的两组(基于使用或不使用保护盖进行定义),基于 Wilcoxon 非参数检验。置信区间为 95%,统计学意义设置为 5%。使用和不使用保护盖进行检查时,图像质量(P=0.646)或使用和不使用屏障方法进行检查时的诊断置信度水平无统计学差异。在声音健康患者中,70°刚性光学视频喉镜检查中使用一次性保护盖不会显著改变通过口腔内牙科相机拍摄的图像质量。