Puckett A, Pratt G
Regional Blood Transfusion Centre, John Radcliffe Hospital, Headington, Oxford.
J Clin Pathol. 1987 Nov;40(11):1337-9. doi: 10.1136/jcp.40.11.1337.
A comparison of cardiolipin and a modified Treponema pallidum haemagglutination assay (TPHA) method over a four year period confirmed the superior sensitivity and specificity of TPHA. In 86,495 new donor sera 19 (0.02%) confirmed positive results were detected by TPHA, 10 of which did not react by the cardiolipin test. In 150,789 antenatal samples 49 confirmed positive results were found by TPHA, 30 of which did not react by cardiolipin. No cardiolipin positive, TPHA negative samples were confirmed as positive by the absorbed fluorescence treponemal antibody test, and overall 78% of cardiolipin reactions gave false biological positive results. Cardiolipin tests were continued only because of their speed. A further modification ("spin") of the TPHA has now been developed which is rapid, sensitive, and inexpensive, and in testing 21,807 sera, gave results equivalent to those of the previous "settle" method. Serious consideration should be given to dispensing with cardiolipin tests.
一项为期四年的关于心磷脂和改良梅毒螺旋体血细胞凝集试验(TPHA)方法的比较,证实了TPHA具有更高的敏感性和特异性。在86495份新的献血者血清中,TPHA检测出19份(0.02%)确诊阳性结果,其中10份在心磷脂试验中无反应。在150789份产前样本中,TPHA发现49份确诊阳性结果,其中30份在心磷脂试验中无反应。没有心磷脂阳性、TPHA阴性的样本通过吸收荧光密螺旋体抗体试验确认为阳性,总体上心磷脂反应中有78%产生了生物学假阳性结果。继续进行心磷脂试验仅仅是因为其速度快。现在已经开发出TPHA的进一步改良方法(“旋转”法),该方法快速、灵敏且成本低廉,在检测21807份血清时,其结果与之前的“沉降”法相当。应认真考虑不再进行心磷脂试验。