Esposti Ongaro Tomaso, Komorowski Jean-Christophe, Legendre Yoann, Neri Augusto
Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia (INGV), Sezione di Pisa, Italy.
Université de Paris, Institut de Physique du Globe de Paris (IPGP), CNRS, Paris, France.
Bull Volcanol. 2020;82(12):76. doi: 10.1007/s00445-020-01411-6. Epub 2020 Nov 13.
We have used a three-dimensional, non-equilibrium multiphase flow numerical model to simulate subplinian eruption scenarios at La Soufrière de Guadeloupe (Lesser Antilles, France). Initial and boundary conditions for computer simulations were set on the basis of independent estimates of eruption source parameters (i.e. mass eruption rate, volatile content, temperature, grain size distribution) from a field reconstruction of the 1530 CE subplinian eruption. This event is here taken as a reference scenario for hazard assessment at La Soufrière de Guadeloupe. A parametric study on eruption source parameters allowed us to quantify their influence on the simulated dynamics and, in particular, the increase of the percentage of column collapse and pyroclastic density current (PDC) intensity, at constant mass eruption rate, with variable vent diameter. Numerical results enabled us to quantify the effects of the proximal morphology on distributing the collapsing mass around the volcano and into deep and long valleys and to estimate the areas invaded by PDCs, their associated temperature and dynamic pressure. Significant impact (temperature > 300 °C and dynamic pressure > 1 kPa) in the inhabited region around the volcano is expected for fully collapsing conditions and mass eruption rates > 2 × 10 kg/s. We thus combine this spatial distribution of temperature and dynamic pressure with an objective consideration of model-related uncertainty to produce preliminary PDC hazard maps for the reference scenario. In such a representation, we identify three areas of varying degree of susceptibility to invasion by PDCs-very likely to be invaded (and highly impacted), susceptible to invasion (and moderately impacted), and unlikely to be invaded (or marginally impacted). The study also raises some key questions about the use of deterministic scenario simulations for hazard assessment, where probability distributions and uncertainties are difficult to estimate. Use of high-performance computing techniques will in part allow us to overcome such difficulties, but the problem remains open in a scientific context where validation of numerical models is still, necessarily, an incomplete and ongoing process. Nevertheless, our findings provide an important contribution to the quantitative assessment of volcanic hazard and risk at La Soufrière de Guadeloupe particularly in the context of the current unrest of the volcano and the need to prepare for a possible future reawakening of the volcano that could culminate in a magmatic explosive eruption.
The online version of this article (10.1007/s00445-020-01411-6) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.
我们使用了一个三维非平衡多相流数值模型来模拟瓜德罗普岛苏弗里耶尔火山(法国小安的列斯群岛)的亚普林尼式火山喷发情景。计算机模拟的初始条件和边界条件是根据对公元1530年亚普林尼式火山喷发的实地重建对喷发源参数(即喷发质量速率、挥发物含量、温度、粒度分布)的独立估计设定的。此次事件在此被用作瓜德罗普岛苏弗里耶尔火山灾害评估的参考情景。对喷发源参数的参数研究使我们能够量化它们对模拟动力学的影响,特别是在恒定喷发质量速率下,随着火山口直径变化,柱状崩塌百分比和火山碎屑流(PDC)强度的增加。数值结果使我们能够量化近端形态对火山周围崩塌物质分布到深而长的山谷中的影响,并估计火山碎屑流侵入的区域、其相关温度和动压力。对于完全崩塌条件和喷发质量速率>2×10 kg/s的情况,预计火山周围有人居住地区会受到显著影响(温度>300°C且动压力>1 kPa)。因此,我们将温度和动压力的这种空间分布与对模型相关不确定性的客观考虑相结合,为参考情景生成初步的火山碎屑流灾害地图。在这样的表示中,我们确定了三个对火山碎屑流侵入敏感度不同的区域——极有可能被侵入(且受到高度影响)、易受侵入(且受到中度影响)以及不太可能被侵入(或受到轻微影响)。该研究还提出了一些关于使用确定性情景模拟进行灾害评估的关键问题,在这种情况下,概率分布和不确定性很难估计。使用高性能计算技术将在一定程度上使我们能够克服这些困难,但在数值模型验证仍然必然是一个不完整且持续的过程的科学背景下,问题仍然存在。尽管如此,我们的研究结果为瓜德罗普岛苏弗里耶尔火山的火山灾害和风险的定量评估做出了重要贡献,特别是在当前火山动荡以及需要为火山未来可能的再次苏醒做准备的背景下,这种苏醒可能最终导致岩浆爆发性喷发。
本文的在线版本(10.1007/s00445 - 020 - 01411 - 6)包含补充材料,授权用户可获取。