Xiang Xiying, Xia Shiwen, Zhu Xing, Gao Xiangyu, Gao Xirong, Zhang Aiming, Lee Shoo K, Hei Mingyan
Neonatal Center, Beijing Children's Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China.
National Center for Child Health, Beijing, China.
Transl Pediatr. 2020 Oct;9(5):603-609. doi: 10.21037/tp-20-60.
Parents in China are denied visitation of their newborns in neonatal intensive care unit (NICU), leading to a prolonged period of parent-infant separation. The family-integrated care (FICare) model, which supports the integration of parents into the NICU team, is gradually being introduced in China. Considering resistance to the implementation of FICare, this study aimed to assess the attitudes and concerns of neonatologists and nurses towards FICare in China.
Using a before and after study design, a qualitative analysis was conducted to determine the perceptions and attitudes of medical professionals towards FICare in China. A total of 34 neonatologists and 94 nurses from 5 tertiary NICUs in China were enrolled. A self-developed questionnaire was used. The study steps included reading session and then survey for the first time (survey 1), a FICare getting buy-in education session (4 hours), a group discussion session, and finally repeat the questionnaire (survey 2). The surveys were completed by trained researchers regarding willingness, acceptance and concerns of implementing FICare in NICUs in China. Differences in attitudes towards FICare were compared between groups (Chi-square/correction for continuity).
There are positive responses in neonatologists and nurses regarding the necessity (Survey 1: 58.8% and 57.4%; Survey 2: 88.2% and 67.0%), feasibility (Survey 1: 17.6% and 19.1%; Survey 2: 32.3% and 34.0%), and interest in joining FICare (Survey 1: 82.4% and 83.0%; Survey 2: 97.1% and 85.1%). A higher proportion of neonatologists indicated that FICare could promote breastfeeding in the NICU comparing to nurses (Survey 1: 47.1% . 19.1%; Survey 2: 61.8% and 46.8% respectively). Most of the neonatologists and nurses are not sure whether FICare can shorten the hospital stay (Survey 1: 82.3% and 68.1%; Survey 2: 85.3% and 60.6%) or improve the doctor-patient relationship (Survey 1: 58.8% and 68.1%; Survey 2: 73.5% and 69.1%). Challenges concerning the implementation of FICare were identified as inadequate ward space, lack of human resources, and potential increases in nosocomial infection.
The getting buy-in education program in introducing new paradigms of neonatal care may help on how to design and implement more effective educational tools for FICare.
在中国,新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)的父母被拒绝探视其新生儿,导致亲子分离时间延长。支持父母融入NICU团队的家庭整合护理(FICare)模式正在中国逐步推行。鉴于FICare实施过程中存在阻力,本研究旨在评估中国新生儿科医生和护士对FICare的态度和担忧。
采用前后对照研究设计,进行定性分析以确定医学专业人员对中国FICare的认知和态度。招募了来自中国5家三级NICU的34名新生儿科医生和94名护士。使用自行编制的问卷。研究步骤包括阅读环节,然后进行首次调查(调查1)、FICare认同教育环节(4小时)、小组讨论环节,最后重复问卷调查(调查2)。由经过培训的研究人员完成调查问卷,内容涉及在中国NICU实施FICare的意愿、接受程度和担忧。比较不同组对FICare态度的差异(卡方检验/连续性校正)。
新生儿科医生和护士对FICare的必要性(调查1:58.8%和57.4%;调查2:88.2%和67.0%)、可行性(调查1:17.6%和19.1%;调查2:32.3%和34.0%)以及参与FICare的兴趣(调查1:82.4%和83.0%;调查2:97.1%和85.1%)均有积极回应。与护士相比,更高比例的新生儿科医生表示FICare可促进NICU中的母乳喂养(调查1:47.1%对19.1%;调查2:分别为61.8%和46.8%)。大多数新生儿科医生和护士不确定FICare是否能缩短住院时间(调查1:82.3%和68.1%;调查2:85.3%和60.6%)或改善医患关系(调查1:58.8%和68.1%;调查2:73.5%和69.1%)。确定FICare实施过程中的挑战包括病房空间不足、人力资源缺乏以及医院感染潜在增加。
引入新生儿护理新模式的认同教育项目可能有助于设计和实施更有效的FICare教育工具。