Chemistry Division, Naval Research Laboratory, Code 6181, 4555 Overlook Ave. SW, Washington, DC, 20375, USA.
Nova Research Inc, 1900 Elkin St. #230, Alexandria, VA, 22308, USA.
Anal Bioanal Chem. 2021 Jan;413(3):955-966. doi: 10.1007/s00216-020-03052-2. Epub 2020 Nov 20.
The canine olfactory system is a highly efficient and intricate tool often exploited by humans for detection for its many attributes, including impressive sensitivity to trace analyte vapors. Canine detectors are often touted as having lower limits of detection, or olfactory detection threshold (ODT), than other field-relevant detection technologies; however, previous attempts to quantify canine ODTs have resulted in reported estimates spanning multiple orders of magnitude, even for the same analyte. A major contributor to these discrepancies is the vapor delivery method used for testing, where losses due to adsorption and dilution are often unaccounted for, and the presence of unattended compounds in the vapor stream due to carryover may go unnoticed. In this research, a trace vapor generator (TV-Gen) was used to deliver quantitatively accurate amounts of vapor reproducibly over time for canine testing. Analyte losses due to adsorption to surfaces in the flow path, dilution in the sniff port at the outlet, and analyte carryover were considered. Computational fluid dynamic (CFD) modeling was used to visualize analyte vapor spread throughout the port. CFD simulations revealed the need for a diffuser to encourage the diffusion of the analyte throughout the port. As a result, the modified vapor generator provides analyte air as a diffuse flow that is evenly distributed through the custom sampling orifice, as opposed to a narrow stream of air at the chosen concentration which exits directly into the environment. Laboratory validations were carried out for three analytes, amyl acetate, 2,4-dinitrotoluene (DNT), and methyl benzoate. A linear response across more than two orders of magnitude vapor concentration range was achieved for all analytes. These efforts will be applied in further research utilizing this TV-Gen vapor delivery system for canine ODT testing, eliminating many quantitative changes seen previously. Graphical abstract.
犬类嗅觉系统是一种高效而复杂的工具,常被人类用于探测,因其具有许多特性,包括对痕量分析物蒸气的惊人敏感性。犬类探测器通常被吹捧为具有比其他现场相关检测技术更低的检测限或嗅觉检测阈值 (ODT);然而,以前试图量化犬类 ODT 的尝试导致了报告的估计值跨越多个数量级,即使对于相同的分析物也是如此。造成这些差异的一个主要因素是用于测试的蒸气输送方法,其中由于吸附和稀释而导致的损失通常未被考虑,并且由于夹带,蒸气流中存在未被注意到的化合物。在这项研究中,痕量蒸气发生器 (TV-Gen) 用于随着时间的推移定量准确地输送蒸气,以进行犬类测试。考虑了由于吸附到流路中的表面、在出口处的嗅探端口中的稀释以及分析物夹带而导致的分析物损失。计算流体动力学 (CFD) 建模用于可视化整个端口中的分析物蒸气的扩散。CFD 模拟揭示了需要扩散器来促进分析物在整个端口中的扩散。因此,改进后的蒸气发生器提供的分析物空气为扩散流,均匀分布在定制采样孔中,而不是直接进入环境的选定浓度的狭窄空气流。对三种分析物,乙酸戊酯、2,4-二硝基甲苯 (DNT) 和苯甲酸甲酯,进行了实验室验证。所有分析物都实现了跨越两个数量级以上的蒸气浓度范围的线性响应。这些努力将应用于进一步的研究中,利用这种 TV-Gen 蒸气输送系统进行犬类 ODT 测试,消除以前看到的许多定量变化。