McKane J P, Robinson A D, Wiles D H, McCreadie R G, Stirling G S
Crichton Royal Hospital, Dumfries.
Br J Psychiatry. 1987 Sep;151:333-6. doi: 10.1192/bjp.151.3.333.
In a double-blind study of 38 chronic schizophrenic in-patients, haloperidol decanoate was compared with fluphenazine decanoate as maintenance therapy over 60 weeks. Both drugs were given by injection at 4-week intervals. Haloperidol and fluphenazine were assumed to be equipotent; the mean starting dose of the former was 127 mg and of the latter 106 mg. The number of withdrawals over 60 weeks was similar in both groups but relapses, strictly defined, were significantly more frequent in the haloperidol group. When patients were switched to haloperidol, Parkinsonism diminished more quickly than in the fluphenazine group, but after 60 weeks there was no difference in severity in the two drug groups. The higher relapse rate and the quicker reduction in Parkinsonism in the haloperidol group might be due to a misjudgement in equivalent doses of the two drugs. Plasma haloperidol steady state levels were reached in most patients by 8-12 weeks. Plasma neuroleptic and prolactin levels, week-by-week systemic drug availability and Parkinsonism showed less variation between injections with haloperidol than with fluphenazine.
在一项针对38名慢性精神分裂症住院患者的双盲研究中,将癸酸氟哌啶醇与癸酸氟奋乃静作为维持疗法进行了60周的比较。两种药物均每4周注射一次。假定氟哌啶醇和氟奋乃静等效;前者的平均起始剂量为127毫克,后者为106毫克。两组在60周内的停药人数相似,但严格定义的复发在氟哌啶醇组中明显更频繁。当患者改用氟哌啶醇时,帕金森症的减轻比氟奋乃静组更快,但60周后两组的严重程度没有差异。氟哌啶醇组较高的复发率和帕金森症更快的减轻可能是由于对两种药物等效剂量的判断错误。大多数患者在8至12周时达到血浆氟哌啶醇稳态水平。与氟奋乃静相比,氟哌啶醇注射之间血浆抗精神病药物和催乳素水平、每周的全身药物可用性以及帕金森症的变化较小。