Royal Veterinary College, Hawkshead Lane, Hatfield, Hertfordshire, United Kingdom.
Department of Basic Medical Veterinary Science, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Jordan University of Science and Technology, Irbid, Jordan.
PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2020 Nov 23;14(11):e0008852. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0008852. eCollection 2020 Nov.
Cutaneous leishmaniasis (CL) is a zoonotic vector-borne neglected tropical disease transmitted by female Phlebotomine sand flies. It is distributed globally but a large proportion of cases (70-75%) are found in just ten countries. CL is endemic in Jordan yet there is a lack of robust entomological data and true reporting status is unknown. This study aimed to map habitat suitability of the main CL vector, Phlebotomus papatasi, in Jordan as a proxy for CL risk distribution to (i) identify areas potentially at risk of CL and (ii) estimate the human population at risk of CL. A literature review identified potential environmental determinants for P. papatasi occurrence including temperature, humidity, precipitation, vegetation, wind speed, presence of human households and presence of the fat sand rat. Each predictor variable was (a) mapped; (b) standardized to a common size, resolution and scale using fuzzy membership functions; (c) assigned a weight using the analytical hierarchy process (AHP); and (d) included within a multicriteria decision analysis (MCDA) model to produce monthly maps illustrating the predicted habitat suitability (between 0 and 1) for P. papatasi in Jordan. Suitability increased over the summer months and was generally highest in the north-western regions of the country and along the Jordan Valley, areas which largely coincided with highly populated parts of the country, including areas where Syrian refugee camps are located. Habitat suitability in Jordan for the main CL vector-P. papatasi-was heterogeneous over both space and time. Suitable areas for P. papatasi coincided with highly populated areas of Jordan which suggests that the targeted implementation of control and surveillance strategies in defined areas such as those with very high CL vector suitability (>0.9 suitability) would focus only on 3.42% of the country's total geographic area, whilst still including a substantial proportion of the population at risk: estimates range from 72% (European Commission's Global Human Settlement population grid) to 89% (Gridded Population of the World) depending on the human population density data used. Therefore, high impact public health interventions could be achieved within a reduced spatial target, thus maximizing the efficient use of resources.
皮肤利什曼病(CL)是一种由雌性白蛉传播的人畜共患媒介传播的被忽视的热带病。它在全球范围内传播,但有很大一部分病例(70-75%)仅发生在十个国家。CL 在约旦流行,但缺乏强有力的昆虫学数据,真实报告情况尚不清楚。本研究旨在绘制约旦主要 CL 传播媒介白蛉埃及亚种的栖息地适宜性图,作为 CL 风险分布的替代指标,(i)确定潜在的 CL 风险区域,(ii)估计 CL 风险人口。文献回顾确定了 P. papatasi 发生的潜在环境决定因素,包括温度、湿度、降水、植被、风速、人类家庭存在和肥尾沙鼠存在。每个预测变量(a)进行映射;(b)使用模糊隶属函数标准化到通用大小、分辨率和比例;(c)使用层次分析法(AHP)分配权重;(d)纳入多准则决策分析(MCDA)模型,以生成每月地图,说明 P. papatasi 在约旦的预测栖息地适宜性(0 到 1 之间)。适宜性在夏季月份增加,总体上在该国西北部地区和约旦河谷最高,这些地区与该国人口稠密地区大致重合,包括叙利亚难民营所在的地区。约旦主要 CL 媒介-P. papatasi 的栖息地适宜性在空间和时间上都存在异质性。P. papatasi 的适宜区域与约旦人口稠密地区重合,这表明在特定区域(如 CL 媒介适宜性非常高(>0.9 适宜性)的区域)有针对性地实施控制和监测策略,将仅关注该国总地理区域的 3.42%,同时仍然包括相当大比例的风险人群:根据使用的人口密度数据,估计范围从 72%(欧盟委员会全球人类住区人口网格)到 89%(世界网格化人口)。因此,可以在缩小的空间目标内实现高影响力的公共卫生干预措施,从而最大限度地提高资源利用效率。