Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience, University College London, London, UK.
Eur J Neurosci. 2021 Mar;53(5):1533-1544. doi: 10.1111/ejn.15063. Epub 2020 Dec 15.
Voluntary actions are preceded by a Readiness Potential (RP), a slow EEG (electroencephalogram) component generated in medial frontal cortical areas. The RP is classically thought to be specific to internally-driven decisions to act, and to reflect post-decision motor preparation. Recent work suggests instead that it may reflect noise or conflict during the decision itself, with internally driven decisions tending to be more random, more conflicted and thus more uncertain than externally driven actions. To contrast accounts based on endogenicity with accounts based on uncertainty, we recorded EEG in a task where participants decided to act or withhold action to accept or reject visually presented gambles, and used multivariate methods to extract an RP-like component. We found no difference in amplitude of this component between actions driven by strong versus weak evidence, suggesting that the RP may not reflect uncertainty. In contrast, the same RP-like component showed higher amplitudes prior to actions performed without any external evidence (guesses) than for actions performed in response to equivocal, conflicting evidence. This supports the view that the RP reflects the internal source of action, rather than decision uncertainty.
自愿行为之前有一个准备电位 (RP),这是一种在额内侧皮质区域产生的缓慢脑电图 (EEG) 成分。RP 被认为是专门针对内部驱动的行动决策的,反映了决策后的运动准备。最近的研究表明,它可能反映了决策过程中的噪声或冲突,内部驱动的决策往往比外部驱动的决策更随机、更冲突,因此更不确定。为了将基于内源性的解释与基于不确定性的解释进行对比,我们在一项任务中记录了 EEG,参与者在该任务中决定是采取行动还是不采取行动来接受或拒绝视觉呈现的赌博,并使用多元方法提取了一个类似于 RP 的成分。我们发现,由强证据驱动的动作与由弱证据驱动的动作之间,这个成分的振幅没有差异,这表明 RP 可能不反映不确定性。相比之下,在没有任何外部证据(猜测)的情况下执行的动作之前,相同的类似于 RP 的成分的振幅高于对模棱两可、冲突证据做出反应的动作之前的振幅。这支持了这样一种观点,即 RP 反映了行动的内部来源,而不是决策的不确定性。