Sedlmayr Brita, Knapp Andreas, Kümmel Michéle, Bathelt Franziska, Sedlmayr Martin
Zentrum für Evidenzbasierte Gesundheitsversorgung, Universitätsklinikum und Medizinische Fakultät Carl Gustav Carus der Technischen Universität Dresden, Dresden, Deutschland; Institut für Medizinische Informatik und Biometrie, Medizinische Fakultät Carl Gustav Carus, Technische Universität Dresden, Dresden, Deutschland.
Zentrum für Evidenzbasierte Gesundheitsversorgung, Universitätsklinikum und Medizinische Fakultät Carl Gustav Carus der Technischen Universität Dresden, Dresden, Deutschland.
Z Evid Fortbild Qual Gesundhwes. 2020 Dec;158-159:81-91. doi: 10.1016/j.zefq.2020.11.002. Epub 2020 Nov 26.
In Germany there are about 4 million people living with a rare disease. Studies have shown that big data applications can improve diagnosis of and research on rare diseases more effectively. However, no concrete comprehensive concept for the use of big data in the care of people with rare diseases has so far been established in Germany. As part of the project "BIDA-SE", which is funded by the German Ministry of Health, a first scenario has been designed to show how big data applications can be usefully incorporated into the care of people with rare diseases.
The aim of the present study was to evaluate this scenario with regard to acceptance, (clinical) benefits, economic aspects, and limitations and barriers to its implementation. To evaluate the scenario, an online survey was conducted in Germany in October/November 2019 amongst a total of N = 9 physicians, N = 69 patients with rare diseases/patient representatives, N = 14 IT experts and N = 21 health care researchers. The online questionnaire consisted of both standardized, validated questions taken from already tested survey instruments and additional questions which were constructed on the basis of a preceding literature analysis. The evaluation of the survey was primarily descriptive, with a calculation of frequencies, mean values and standard deviations.
The results of the evaluation show that the scenario has been accepted by a majority of all groups surveyed (physicians, patients/patient representatives, IT experts and health care researchers). From the point of view of physicians, patients/patient representatives and health care researchers, the scenario has the potential to accelerate the diagnosis and initiation of therapy and to improve cross-sectoral treatment. From the physician's and health care researcher's perspective, investments in the application presented in the scenario would be profitable. Financing the scenario would, however, require adjusting the reimbursement situation. The limitations and barriers identified by all groups for a medium-term implementation of the scenario can be grouped into seven thematic areas where action is needed: (1) financing and investment, (2) data protection and data security, (3) standards/data sources/data quality, (4) acceptance of technology, (5) integration into the daily work routine, (6) knowledge about availability as well as (7) habits and preferences/physician's role.
With the present study, a first interdisciplinary, practical scenario using big data applications was evaluated with regard to acceptance, benefits and limitations/barriers. The scenario is widely accepted among the majority of all surveyed target groups and is considered (clinically) useful, although legal, organisational and technical barriers still need to be overcome for its medium-term implementation. The evaluation results contribute to the derivation of recommendations for action to ensure the medium-term implementation of the scenario and to channel access to the Centres for Rare Diseases in the future.
Many activities have been initiated at a national level to improve the health care situation of people with rare diseases. The scenario developed in the "BIDA-SE" project complements these research activities and illustrates how big data applications can be usefully implemented into practice to improve the diagnosis and therapy of people with rare diseases in a sustainable way.
在德国,约有400万人患有罕见病。研究表明,大数据应用能够更有效地改善罕见病的诊断和研究。然而,德国目前尚未建立关于在罕见病患者护理中使用大数据的具体综合概念。作为由德国卫生部资助的“BIDA - SE”项目的一部分,已设计出首个方案,以展示如何将大数据应用有效地纳入罕见病患者的护理中。
本研究的目的是从接受度、(临床)益处、经济方面以及实施的限制和障碍等方面评估该方案。为评估该方案,2019年10月/11月在德国开展了一项在线调查,共涉及N = 9名医生、N = 69名罕见病患者/患者代表、N = 14名信息技术专家以及N = 21名医疗保健研究人员。在线问卷既包括从已测试的调查工具中选取的标准化、经过验证的问题,也包括基于先前文献分析构建的其他问题。对调查的评估主要是描述性的,计算了频率、均值和标准差。
评估结果表明,该方案已被大多数接受调查的群体(医生、患者/患者代表、信息技术专家和医疗保健研究人员)所接受。从医生、患者/患者代表和医疗保健研究人员的角度来看,该方案有可能加快诊断和治疗的启动,并改善跨部门治疗。从医生和医疗保健研究人员的角度看,对该方案中所呈现的应用进行投资将是有利可图的。然而,为该方案提供资金需要调整报销情况。所有群体确定的该方案中期实施的限制和障碍可归纳为七个需要采取行动的主题领域:(1)融资和投资,(2)数据保护和数据安全,(3)标准/数据来源/数据质量,(4)技术接受度,(5)融入日常工作流程,(6)对可用性的了解以及(7)习惯和偏好/医生的角色。
通过本研究,首个使用大数据应用的跨学科实际方案在接受度、益处和限制/障碍方面得到了评估。该方案在大多数接受调查的目标群体中得到广泛认可,并被认为(在临床上)是有用的,尽管在中期实施时仍需克服法律、组织和技术障碍。评估结果有助于得出行动建议,以确保该方案的中期实施,并在未来引导人们获得罕见病治疗中心的服务。
国家层面已开展多项活动以改善罕见病患者的医疗状况。“BIDA - SE ”项目中制定的方案补充了这些研究活动,并说明了如何将大数据应用有效地付诸实践,以可持续的方式改善罕见病患者的诊断和治疗。