Cash Rebecca E, Clay Carson E, Leggio William J, Camargo Carlos A
Prehosp Emerg Care. 2021 Jan 12:1-9. doi: 10.1080/10903127.2020.1856984.
The geographic distribution and access to paramedic education programs is unclear but often cited as a reason for emergency medical services (EMS) workforce shortages. Our aims were: 1) to examine the spatial distribution of accredited paramedic programs and 2) to compare characteristics of communities with and without existing programs. We performed a cross-sectional study of US paramedic education programs accredited by the Commission on Accreditation of Allied Health Education Programs as of April 2020. Program locations were geocoded to county, and population estimates from the US Census Bureau were used to determine the adult population within the program's potential catchment area (30, 50, and 100 miles). Clustering of programs was examined using Moran's I. We compared community characteristics obtained from the 2018 American Community Survey, 2018-2019 Area Health Resources Files, and 2018 National Emergency Department Inventory between counties with and without programs. Logistic regression models were used to determine associations of community characteristics and existence of a paramedic program, controlling for urbanicity. There were 790 paramedic program locations in the US, located in 596/3142 (19%) counties. Every state, except Rhode Island and Washington, DC, had at least one paramedic program site. The population within potential catchment areas ranged from 182 million (30 miles) to 248 million (100 miles), representing 73% to 99% of the US adult population, respectively. However, among counties classified as rural (n = 644), this decreased to 22% (30 miles) to 95% (100 miles). There was significant clustering of programs (p < 0.001). There were significantly higher odds of having a paramedic program for counties classified as metro compared to non-metro (OR 4.42, 95% CI 3.60-5.42) and with the presence of healthcare resources (e.g., emergency department in the county: OR 2.42, 95% CI 1.87-3.14). : Approximately 73% of the US adult population lives within 30 miles of an existing paramedic education program; however, this decreases to 22% in rural areas. Geographic barriers to accessing paramedic education remain a challenge for ongoing efforts to address the rural EMS workforce shortage.
护理人员教育项目的地理分布以及获取情况尚不清楚,但这经常被认为是紧急医疗服务(EMS)劳动力短缺的一个原因。我们的目标是:1)研究经认可的护理人员项目的空间分布,以及2)比较有和没有现有项目的社区的特征。我们对截至2020年4月获得联合健康职业教育认证委员会认可的美国护理人员教育项目进行了一项横断面研究。项目地点被地理编码到县,美国人口普查局的人口估计数据被用来确定项目潜在服务区域(30英里、50英里和100英里)内的成年人口。使用莫兰指数(Moran's I)来检验项目的聚类情况。我们比较了从2018年美国社区调查、2018 - 2019年区域卫生资源文件以及2018年国家急诊科库存中获取的有项目和无项目县之间的社区特征。使用逻辑回归模型来确定社区特征与护理人员项目存在之间的关联,并控制城市化程度。美国有790个护理人员项目地点,分布在596/3142(19%)个县。除罗德岛州和华盛顿特区外,每个州至少有一个护理人员项目地点。潜在服务区域内的人口从1.82亿(30英里)到2.48亿(100英里)不等,分别占美国成年人口的73%至99%。然而,在被归类为农村的县(n = 644)中,这一比例降至22%(30英里)至95%(100英里)。项目存在显著聚类(p < 0.001)。与非都市县相比,被归类为都市的县拥有护理人员项目的几率显著更高(比值比4.42,95%置信区间3.60 - 5.42),并且有医疗资源(例如,县内有急诊科:比值比2.42,95%置信区间1.87 - 3.14)。大约73%的美国成年人口居住在现有护理人员教育项目30英里范围内;然而,在农村地区这一比例降至22%。获取护理人员教育的地理障碍仍然是解决农村EMS劳动力短缺持续努力中的一个挑战。