Institute for Health and Social Policy, McGill University, 1130 Pine Avenue West, Montréal, Quebec, H3A 1A3, Canada.
Department of Public Health Sciences, Queen's University, Carruthers Hall, 62 Fifth Field Company Lane, Kingston, Ontario, K7L 3N6, Canada.
Soc Sci Med. 2021 Jan;268:113556. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2020.113556. Epub 2020 Nov 28.
Food insecurity contributes to various stress-related health problems and previous research found that its association with mental illness is stronger in more affluent countries. We hypothesised that this pattern is a function of relative deprivation whereby the severity of individual food insecurity relative to others in a reference group determines its associations with mental health and wellbeing after differences in absolute food insecurity are controlled for. Using survey data from the Gallup World Poll collected in 160 countries and a measure of relative deprivation (Yitzhaki index), we found that relative food insecurity-based on national or regional reference groups-related to more mental health symptoms, lower positive wellbeing and lower life satisfaction after controlling for absolute food insecurity, household income, and country differences. Our analysis also found that relative food insecurity was more strongly related to mental health and wellbeing where the prevalence of food insecurity was lower. The findings underscore the negative health consequences of material deprivation and unfavourable social comparisons. Consistent with relative deprivation theory, individuals who live with constant worries about not getting enough food, have to skip meals, or face chronic hunger are deprived of material and social resources that support mental health and wellbeing, especially in settings where food insecurity is less common and potentially more stigmatised. The implications of these findings for global food policy and surveillance efforts are discussed.
食物不安全会导致各种与压力相关的健康问题,先前的研究发现,其与精神疾病的关联在较富裕的国家中更强。我们假设,这种模式是相对剥夺的一种表现,即个体相对于参照群体中其他人的食物不安全程度的严重程度决定了在控制绝对食物不安全差异后,其与心理健康和幸福感的关联。我们使用盖洛普世界民意调查(Gallup World Poll)在 160 个国家收集的数据和相对剥夺指标(Yitzhaki 指数)进行研究,发现基于国家或地区参照群体的相对食物不安全(即基于国家或地区参照群体的相对食物不安全)与更多的心理健康症状、较低的积极幸福感和较低的生活满意度相关,在控制了绝对食物不安全、家庭收入和国家差异之后。我们的分析还发现,在食物不安全更为普遍的情况下,相对食物不安全与心理健康和幸福感的关联更为密切。这些发现强调了物质剥夺和不利的社会比较对健康造成的负面影响。与相对剥夺理论一致的是,那些经常担心得不到足够食物、不得不少吃一顿饭或面临长期饥饿的人,会被剥夺支持心理健康和幸福感的物质和社会资源,尤其是在食物不安全现象不太普遍且可能更具污名化的环境中。这些发现对全球粮食政策和监测工作的意义将在文中讨论。