Department of Psychology, The University of California, Riverside, California, United States of America.
Department of Psychology, The University of Houston, Houston, Texas, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2020 Dec 9;15(12):e0242718. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0242718. eCollection 2020.
What does it mean to be happy? The vast majority of cross-cultural studies on happiness have employed a Western-origin, or "WEIRD" measure of happiness that conceptualizes it as a self-centered (or "independent"), high-arousal emotion. However, research from Eastern cultures, particularly Japan, conceptualizes happiness as including an interpersonal aspect emphasizing harmony and connectedness to others. Following a combined emic-etic approach (Cheung, van de Vijver & Leong, 2011), we assessed the cross-cultural applicability of a measure of independent happiness developed in the US (Subjective Happiness Scale; Lyubomirsky & Lepper, 1999) and a measure of interdependent happiness developed in Japan (Interdependent Happiness Scale; Hitokoto & Uchida, 2015), with data from 63 countries representing 7 sociocultural regions. Results indicate that the schema of independent happiness was more coherent in more WEIRD countries. In contrast, the coherence of interdependent happiness was unrelated to a country's "WEIRD-ness." Reliabilities of both happiness measures were lowest in African and Middle Eastern countries, suggesting these two conceptualizations of happiness may not be globally comprehensive. Overall, while the two measures had many similar correlates and properties, the self-focused concept of independent happiness is "WEIRD-er" than interdependent happiness, suggesting cross-cultural researchers should attend to both conceptualizations.
幸福是什么?绝大多数关于幸福的跨文化研究都采用了一种源于西方的、或被称为“WEIRD”的幸福衡量标准,将其概念化为一种以自我为中心(或“独立”)、高唤醒的情绪。然而,来自东方文化,尤其是日本的研究将幸福概念化为包括人际关系方面,强调与他人的和谐和联系。我们采用了一种综合的本土-西方方法(Cheung、van de Vijver 和 Leong,2011),评估了一种在美国开发的独立幸福衡量标准(主观幸福感量表;Lyubomirsky 和 Lepper,1999)和一种在日本开发的相互依赖幸福衡量标准(相互依赖幸福感量表;Hitokoto 和 Uchida,2015)在 63 个代表 7 个社会文化区域的国家中的跨文化适用性。结果表明,独立幸福的模式在更多的 WEIRD 国家中更具一致性。相比之下,相互依赖幸福的一致性与一个国家的“WEIRD-ness”无关。这两种幸福感衡量标准的可靠性在非洲和中东国家最低,这表明这两种幸福感概念在全球范围内可能并不全面。总的来说,虽然这两种衡量标准有许多相似的相关性和特性,但以自我为中心的独立幸福概念比相互依赖的幸福概念更“WEIRD”,这表明跨文化研究人员应该关注这两种概念。